Sunday, December 04, 2005

Chemical Nonsense

In early November, the left-wing British Independent paper found a new way to argue against Operation Iraqi Freedom:
Powerful new evidence emerged yesterday that the United States dropped massive quantities of white phosphorus on the Iraqi city of Fallujah during the attack on the city in November 2004, killing insurgents and civilians with the appalling burns that are the signature of this weapon.
The paper's source was a recently released film from Italian Rai News24, an offshoot of communist-dominated channel Rai 3 called Fallujah: The Hidden Massacre. A montage of footage from Vietnam and Iraq, the film purported to show attacks using white phosphorus by, and casualties from, US forces in Fallujah one year ago. Naturally, the accusation immediately crossed the Atlantic, igniting a feeding frenzy among liberal newspapers, liberal bloggers, and loony liberals at Kos and Think Progress, each claiming that phosphorus is a banned chemical weapon under international law. Al Jazeera played it as proof of American hypocrisy, as did Al Jazeera's US bureau chief, Cindy Sheehan.

One problem with the accusations--they're wrong. But first some background on White Phosphorus.

Phosphorus is a chemical element with the atomic number 15. It was first identified in 1669 by Hennig Brand, who isolated it from human urine. White phosphorus is a particular allotropic form (i.e., not in a compound with other elements) consisting of four phosphorus atoms, i.e., P4.

According to Global Security:
White Phosphorus (WP), known as Willy Pete, is used for signaling, screening, and incendiary purposes. White Phosphorus can be used to destroy the enemy's equipment or to limit his vision. It is used against vehicles, petroleum, oils and lubricants (POL) and ammunition storage areas, and enemy observers. WP can be used as an aid in target location and navigation. It is usually dispersed by explosive munitions. It can be fired with fuze time to obtain an airburst. White phosphorus was used most often during World War II in military formulations for smoke screens, marker shells, incendiaries, hand grenades, smoke markers, colored flares, and tracer bullets.

The Battle of Fallujah was conducted from 8 to 20 November 2004 with the last fire mission on 17 November. The battle was fought by an Army, Marine and Iraqi force of about 15,000 under the I Marine Expeditionary Force (IMEF). US forces found WP to be useful in the Battle of Fallujah. "WP proved to be an effective and versatile munition. We used it for screening missions at two breeches and, later in the fight, as a potent psychological weapon against the insurgents in trench lines and spider holes when we could not get effects on them with HE. We fired “shake and bake” missions at the insurgents, using WP to flush them out and HE to take them out. ... We used improved WP for screening missions when HC smoke would have been more effective and saved our WP for lethal missions."
So the U.S. did use WP in Iraq, albeit in narrow circumstances as described below.

But Phosphorus is not an unlawful chemical weapon under the Chemical Weapons Convention. Article II of that treaty says Chemical Weapons include "Toxic chemicals and their precursors, except where intended for purposes not prohibited under this Convention." (A precursor is "any chemical reactant which takes part at any stage in the production by whatever method of a toxic chemical.") Article IV of that treaty ties the definition to the treaty's Annex on Chemicals, which lists (as precursors) "Chemicals. . .containing a phosphorous atom to which is bonded one methyl, ethyl, or propyl (normal or iso) group.” White Phosphorus, however, is not a compound, consisting of four phosphorus atoms only.

No reputable person or entity says otherwise. For example, the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons -- the international body responsible for chemical treaty verification -- flatly states, "Incendiary agents such as napalm and phosphorus are not considered to be CW agents since they achieve their effect mainly through thermal energy." Global Security agrees:
White phosphorus is not banned by any treaty to which the United States is a signatory. Smokes and obscurants comprise a category of materials that are not used militarily as direct chemical agents. The United States retains its ability to employ incendiaries to hold high-priority military targets at risk in a manner consistent with the principle of proportionality that governs the use of all weapons under existing law. The use of white phosphorus or fuel air explosives are not prohibited or restricted by Protocol II of the Certain Conventional Weapons Convention (CCWC), the Convention on Prohibitions or Restrictions on the Use of Certain Conventional Weapons which may be Deemed to be Excessively Injurious or to have Indiscriminate Effects.
After the initial furor, lefties and the media acknowledged the lawfulness of WP for illumination under the CWC, but claimed either that its use as an incendiary was banned or that WP was lawful only because the United States never ratified the so-called Protocol III on the Use of Incendiary Weapons. Even were the US a party,1 however, it wouldn't outlaw US actions--Article II of that agreement protects civilians, not terrorists:
1. It is prohibited in all circumstances to make the civilian population as such, individual civilians or civilian objects the object of attack by incendiary weapons.

2. It is prohibited in all circumstances to make any military objective located within a concentration of civilians the object of attack by air-delivered incendiary weapons.

3. It is further prohibited to make any military objective located within a concentration of civilians the object of attack by means of incendiary weapons other than air-delivered incendiary weapons, except when such military objective is clearly separated from the concentration of civilians and all feasible precautions are taken with a view to limiting the incendiary effects to the military objective and to avoiding, and in any event to minimizing, incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilians and damage to civilian objects.
Although the Russians and a few lefties are stuck on stupid,2 most in the global media and the blogosphere backed off claims of illegality, but insisted America's allegedly indiscriminate WP use was immoral and violated the laws of land warfare when used against civilians. So did the US over-use WP or fail to protect innocents?

No, says General Peter Pace Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff:
U.S. forces have never used white phosphorous to target innocent civilians, officials said, and have taken great pains to avoid doing so.

Just as with any other weapon, troops use a variety of factors to determine the appropriateness of using white phosphorous, explained Air Force Maj. Todd Vician, a Pentagon spokesman. These include the target vulnerability and location, available munitions, and the potential risk to civilians and friendly forces, he said.

"No armed force in the world goes to greater effort than your armed force to protect civilians and to be very precise in the way we apply our power," Pace said.
As UK blogger Scott Burgess notes, in Fallujah, "'civilians were ordered to evacuate in advance'; which, incidentally, seems a good method of 'tak[ing] every feasible precaution to spare civilians and to respect the principles of distinction and proportionality in all operations', as the Red Cross demands." Indeed, even the BBC admits the US army encountered few civilians in Fallujah. In any event, WP is ill-suited for mass genocide.

As it happens, no actual witness claims the US used WP against civilians--participants deny the charge. And the photos in the Italian film (and by other anti-war activists elsewhere) supply no "hard" evidence; indeed, the film depicts casualties that could not have been attacked with WP, as Confederate Yankee brilliantly and painstakingly (and graphically) proves. Simply put, tales of mass civilian atrocities using WP are lies.

Conclusion. Sure the US used White Phosphorus against armed terrorists in Iraq. What of it?, asks Global Security's Director, John Pike:
WP . . has remained a standard part of the U.S. arsenal. The U.S. military used it in the retaking of Fallouja a year ago. It is nasty stuff, but war is nasty. . .
Not all chemicals used in war are chemical weapons--and alternative weapons might be worse.

Importantly, we don't target civilians in general or with WP in particular--those claiming otherwise are lying. Rather, our goal is killing terrorists. As Scott Burgress concludes, buying the lies and spinning the evidence is one facet of "the Holy Grail of a certain kind of antiwar activist: to establish a moral equivalence between the US and Saddam Hussein." That's outrageous anti-Americanism--and simple slander.

Former paratrooper Michael Fumento, an attorney and journalist who was embedded with the 2nd Marine Expeditionary Force at Camp Fallujah, says: "the greatest threat to Iraqi civilians are the terrorists. If we want to save civilians, our soldiers must be free to use the best legal equipment available to kill those terrorists and to continue liberating Iraq." Agreed.
_______________________

1 President Clinton recommended against ratifying Protocol III, or ratifying only with a reservation, out of concern that the agreement could be read to prohibit use of White Phosphorus.

2 Those citing to the 1907 Convention on Laws and Customs of War on Land (which is part of US law) fail explain to why WP has been widely used for over a century, by American, Russian and other armies, without charge or prosecution. Indeed, WP figured in several awards of the Congressional Medal of Honor.


(via Balloon Juice, Outside the Beltway)

Saturday, December 03, 2005

Get Along Home, Cindy, Cindy

Michael Saunders at Sparks from the Anvil put together the definitive video take-down of Cindy Sheehan--it's called "The Spark that Lit the Fire."

Show Me Your Badge

Stop the world--I'm tired of unsupported liberal hysteria: "For all the hype about an "illegal" war or "treasonous" leaks, leftists never seem to be able to point to any actual law the Administration violated." I've already shown the Administration hasn't acted inconsistently with the Geneva Conventions; nor, by the way, has Bush trampled the Chemical Weapons Treaty. Though no one can warrant against individual atrocities committed by soldiers acting contrary to orders, the Global War on Terror is consisent with U.S. treaties.

But what if it weren't? What if the President determined that preserving the safety and security of the United States required actions inconsistent with treaty? This question is anything but hypothetical in the current debate about torture. It's also germane to the legality of the Iraq invasion itself--I've argued that the shift from containment to preemption is consistent with Article 51 of the UN Charter, which cannot force sovereigns to accept a destructive "first bite" by an armed group or state. (There's also the "treaties aren't self executing" argument, which rules out most sanctions for treaty violations.)

So, assume the President, in protecting America and its residents, knowingly chooses a course inconsistent with a ratified treaty. Is that unlawful?

No, though this point is widely misunderstood. Article II, Section 2 of the Constitution makes the President "Commander in Chief of the Army and Navy of the United States." In that role, Bush lawfully can act inconsistent with treaties because the Constitution is "the supreme Law of the Land":
It would be manifestly contrary to the objectives of those who created the Constitution, as well as those who were responsible for the Bill of Rights - let alone alien to our entire constitutional history and tradition - to construe Article VI as permitting the United States to exercise power under an international agreement without observing constitutional prohibitions. In effect, such construction would permit amendment of that document in a manner not sanctioned by Article V. The prohibitions of the Constitution were designed to apply to all branches of the National Government and they cannot be nullified by the Executive or by the Executive and the Senate combined.
Reid v. Covert, 354 U.S. 1, 17 (1957) (plurality opinion) (footnotes omitted). See also Doe v. Braden, 57 U.S. (16 How.) 635, 656 (1853) ("The treaty is . . . a law made by the proper authority, and the courts of justice have no right to annul or disregard any of its provisions, unless they violate the Constitution of the United States.").

Contrary to unsourced lefty assertions, this point is well settled. Indeed, Congress itself often recognizes that the Constitution trumps treaties, for example when ratifying the Chemical Weapons Convention during the Clinton Administration (S. Res. 75, 105th Cong., 1st Sess., Section 12):
Primacy of the united states constitution:
Nothing in the Convention requires or authorizes legislation, or other action, by the United States prohibited by the Constitution of the United States, as interpreted by the United States.
That resolution passed 74-26, 144 Cong. Rec. S 3651 (April 24, 1997). Democrats voting "yea" included Senators Boxer, Feingold, Inouye, Kennedy, Kerry, Reid and Rockefeller.

How quickly they forget. Obviously, a new and dangerous mutation of WMD Amnesia.

Thursday, December 01, 2005

World's Longest Personal Ad

Somewhere in nearby Northern Virginia, this 36 year old guy -- "5ft8, 160 pounds, shaved head, facial hair and a little ethnic looking" -- wants a wife:
I know my job and I own up to it, I learned the hard way - but I own up to it now. My job is to be decisive when you say "what do you want to do tonight?" My job is NOT to say, "I dunno, what do you want to do?" It is my job to say, "I would like to [verb here] to [insert place] and [activity here]. Yet, I must also know when you have your own idea and actually want me to say, "I don't know, what about you?" How should I know? That's my job as a man. I must know. I do know.

My job is to pay for dinner even if you say you want to pay half. My job is to be ambitious in my career and make enough money that if we live together and your career takes a turn for the worse - I would have the money to afford to keep you fed and healthy AND sexy (we will talk about you being sexy below).

My job is [to] make you feel safe with me. If I have to act like a psycho killer once in a while when someone is being threatening around you and endangering your well being, even if it means I might end up in jail for the night (when I break his arm and jaw for trying to rape you), I do it. Yet I need to know when to be cool and aloof most of the time when you are just engaged in friendly flirting. I have to NOT feel threatened when guys stare at you, not be jealous when they flirt, not be insecure when you flirt back, just relax and enjoy your happiness. Ok? I figured it out. I know. I am not jealous by nature so this job is easy. But the moment a guy mistakes one of your signals (which happens because you don't quite realize all the signals you give off) and starts trying to do something to you against your will, I need to be ready to be incarcerated after I make him sorry. That's fine. . .

Now you: There are many jobs for you. Your first and last job are the same. The rest of the list is important too, but they don't work if you don’t do your first job first. Your first job is to be sexy in the way that you can be. It is your job to discover your own natural sexiness, manifest it, AND your job to figure out what I think is sexy. How do you normally attract men? If you think it is by wearing your thong above your jeans so that everyone can see it - then you are a moron. If you think it is getting wasted at some club and making out with your best girl-friend while guys cheer - you are an idiot. I have met you already, you bore me. I think you need to pull your pants up, drink less, bathe more and try to be more original than the Girls Gone Wild video that your former boyfriends got boners watching. . .

Your other jobs are very important as well. It is your job to nurture. If I am down and not feeling so great, you need to be building me back up. You need to be reading self-help books once in a while and see to it that we are both emotionally balanced. You need to make sure that we both communicate what is bothering us and all that stuff that you women want us to talk about in relationships. I need that. Do your job, I respect it. And when I am not feeling like such a man, you need to find it in yourself, even if you have to fake it, to build me right back into the alpha male that I should be.
There's much, much more. Act now, ladies, before Beth claims him.

More:

The post has been "removed by the craiglist community"--commutarian-speak for "censored." However, the same personal appeared on Craigslist in March (and still is available), suggesting the ad's a spoof.

(via My Vast Right Wing Conspiracy)

Photo of the Day

An October 2001 BBC article I'd overlooked:
Photographs of Osama Bin Laden on a visit to Oxford in 1971 have come to light after their owner recognised him in widely-publicised pictures from the same year.

The pictures are owned by a Spanish woman and one has been published in a Spanish newspaper showing 14-year-old Bin Laden with two of his brothers and two glamorous Spanish girls as they attended a language course. . .


Bin Laden on the right (source: BBC)

Saudi-born Bin Laden did not appear to be into rock music or fashion, and did not like the 1970s London scene, the El Correo newspaper reported.

He used to tell the Spanish girls that the foreigners who walked around London were a bit crazy.

The photograph was taken in an Oxford park, where the woman recalled going for a walk one evening after taking tea.

Bin Laden appears with his older brothers and seems a gangly teenager, with a slightly awkward smile.
Too bad Bin Laden's stay in Britain didn't include attending the civilizing Rugby School of Dr. Thomas Arnold and Tom Brown's Schooldays--though he still might have ended up like Harry Flashman, V.C., K.C.B., K.C.I.E.

(via Opinionated Bastard)

Wednesday, November 30, 2005

Why Can't Johnny Media Read?

December 1, 2005 -- New York Times page 1 headline:
Bush Again Rejects Calls for a Withdrawal Timetable in Iraq.
November 18, 2005 -- MSMBC story:
Pentagon and U.S. military officials tell NBC News the plan calls for the substantial withdrawal of more than 60,000 troops from Iraq. The plan was drafted by Gen. John Abizaid and Gen. George Casey, the two top U.S. commanders of the war.

If Iraqi elections are successful in December and a new parliament seated by January, withdrawal could begin almost immediately.
November 12, 2005 -- DoD response to Pierce Wetter's question:
We can confirm that the plan is, in fact, to reduce the size of Coalition Forces in country in 2006. It's big news inasmuch as the Iraqis are increasing the size and strength of their footprint and, by the same token, we're reducing ours.
November 8, 2005 -- DoD Operation Iraqi Freedom Today video briefing:
The Defense Department hopes to reduce troop levels to 92,000 by next year.
November 7, 2005 -- Department of Defense News Release No. 1156-05:
The Department of Defense announced today the major units scheduled to deploy as part of the next Operation Iraqi Freedom rotation. This announcement involves several combat brigades, headquarters elements, and combat support and combat service support units and approximately 92,000 service members as presently envisioned. The scheduled rotation for these forces will begin in mid-2006.
Bush's speech today didn't reject withdraw; rather, recognizing fluidity on the ground, the President ruled out unbreakable deadlines.

Oh, if you're wondering, Representative John Murtha's failed cut-and-run resolution came later -- it was introduced November 17, 2005, ten days after DoD's November 7th decision. Proving that even an extra three weeks of fact checking couldn't turn the Times into truth.

(via Opinionated Bastard, Defense Tech and Mudville Gazette)

Raising on a Busted Flush

Unsatisfied with broadcasting their ineptness on all things military, forcing withdraw of their new the TV ad, MoveOn.Org today published pure propaganda. First noticed by (non-twin)-brothers-of-different-blogs (GOP and the City and GOP and College), MO.O chose cover-up, as Harvey at Bad Example explains:
Normally I'd just say "buncha dumbasses" and ignore it, but as we all know, it's not the lie, it's the cover-up that'll bring you down.

In the sidebar picture, they show Mr. Shorts wearing pants.

But not just ANY pants - the same exact pants as the guy standing next to him.

This presents some problems, since they're not standing at the same angle, but they hoped no one would notice.

Sorry guys, it's just not your day. . .

First, a screenshot of the MO.O site, so you can see the pictures side-by-side (and as proof that it actually happened, in case they take it down - remember: ALWAYS GET A SCREENSHOT).

Second, greatly enlarged side-by-side comparison of the fake pic (left) and the real pic (right). In the fake pic, notice that the camouflage pattern - right down to the wrinkles and reflection of the sunlight - is EXACTLY the same on both pairs (with allowances for distortion due to photoshopping).

Yet if you look at their feet, you'll see that they're standing at different angles. Which makes for a VERY strange effect for the left soldier: although his right foot is slightly behind him, and you should see the butt-crack of his pants (as you do in the shorts pic), you actually see the front of his pants.
Were similar fakery found in a spot from, say, the Swiftboat Veterans for Truth, the press would launch a fortnight of finger-wagging, faulting Karl Rove. I'd call it Nixonian--'cpt Tricky Dick knew more about the military and magnetic tape than any lefty.

(via Michelle Malkin and Mark in Mexico)

Tuesday, November 29, 2005

Leftist Turkeys

Update: MoveOn.Org's latest atrocity is here.

Ultra liberal blogger Sally Swift pointed to a new anti-war MoveOn.Org ad contrasting Thanksgiving splendor in the homeland with the privations of our troops in the Middle East. The voice-over blames Bush for "a hundred and fifty thousand American men and women . . . stuck in Iraq," while the camera scans this photo:


(source: MoveOn.Org)

As usual, lefties forget that ours in a voluntary military which overwhelmingly supports continued deployment in Iraq and Afghanistan. That's in part because they rarely meet soldiers, as demonstrated by a Best of the Web reader:
I just got back from my third deployment from Iraq on Friday, and I happened to be at the dentist and saw a completely offensive ad from the idiots at MoveOn.org this morning. Anyway, it is a Bush-bashing ad that pretends to be arguing for American soldiers families as they will miss the holidays and it shows turkey and crying wives and blames Bush for it all. Here is the crucial part of the ad that I would like to bring to your attention. As they pretend to argue on my behalf, they show a group of soldiers standing around a table in the Middle East.

These are not your normal everyday U.S. soldiers though. If you look at the frame they are actually British soldiers. One is in shorts (we don't have shorts as a normal combat uniform) and the others are all clearly wearing British pattern fatigues. So, my point is that these [turkeys] pretend to argue on my behalf and bash the president in the name of my crying wife, and they don't even know what an American soldier looks like! Anyway, it really [ticked] me off.
No wonder lefties like MoveOn.Org don't support the troops--they don't even know them.

Corrected 8:15pm

One Good Dem

Kudos to Senator Joe Lieberman:
Lieberman has visited Iraq four times in 17 months. He said there are signs life is returning to normal, including a profusion of cell phones and satellite TV dishes on rooftops.

"About two-thirds of the country is in really pretty good shape," he said, noting most attacks are in the so-called "Sunni Triangle" region. "Overall, I came back encouraged."

Lieberman said he hopes President Bush's speech Tuesday night will give a clearer picture to the American public of the progress being made in the war.

"It's time for some details," said Lieberman. "He's gotta describe some of the progress that I saw there. It's gotta be realistic."

U.S. military officials told him they hope that by next year, two-thirds of Iraq's military will be able to carry the fight to insurgents with limited logistical support from U.S. forces. Lieberman said U.S. commanders had learned from their early mistakes and were successfully pursuing a "clear-hold-build" strategy against rebel forces.

He cautioned, however, that "prematurely" pulling out U.S. forces would jeopardize the progress made thus far.
More:

Senator Lieberman's op-ed in today's Wall Street Journal:
Progress is visible and practical. In the Kurdish North, there is continuing security and growing prosperity. The primarily Shiite South remains largely free of terrorism, receives much more electric power and other public services than it did under Saddam, and is experiencing greater economic activity. The Sunni triangle, geographically defined by Baghdad to the east, Tikrit to the north and Ramadi to the west, is where most of the terrorist enemy attacks occur. And yet here, too, there is progress.

There are many more cars on the streets, satellite television dishes on the roofs, and literally millions more cell phones in Iraqi hands than before. All of that says the Iraqi economy is growing. And Sunni candidates are actively campaigning for seats in the National Assembly. People are working their way toward a functioning society and economy in the midst of a very brutal, inhumane, sustained terrorist war against the civilian population and the Iraqi and American military there to protect it.

It is a war between 27 million and 10,000; 27 million Iraqis who want to live lives of freedom, opportunity and prosperity and roughly 10,000 terrorists who are either Saddam revanchists, Iraqi Islamic extremists or al Qaeda foreign fighters who know their wretched causes will be set back if Iraq becomes free and modern. The terrorists are intent on stopping this by instigating a civil war to produce the chaos that will allow Iraq to replace Afghanistan as the base for their fanatical war-making. We are fighting on the side of the 27 million because the outcome of this war is critically important to the security and freedom of America. If the terrorists win, they will be emboldened to strike us directly again and to further undermine the growing stability and progress in the Middle East, which has long been a major American national and economic security priority. . .

Every time the 27 million Iraqis have been given the chance since Saddam was overthrown, they have voted for self-government and hope over the violence and hatred the 10,000 terrorists offer them. Most encouraging has been the behavior of the Sunni community, which, when disappointed by the proposed constitution, registered to vote and went to the polls instead of taking up arms and going to the streets. Last week, I was thrilled to see a vigorous political campaign, and a large number of independent television stations and newspapers covering it.

None of these remarkable changes would have happened without the coalition forces led by the U.S. And, I am convinced, almost all of the progress in Iraq and throughout the Middle East will be lost if those forces are withdrawn faster than the Iraqi military is capable of securing the country.

Monday, November 28, 2005

Canada's Liberals Fall; Election Jan. 23rd

Canada's slow-moving "Adscam" corruption scandal finally claimed a victim: Canada's Liberal government, which lost a no-confidence vote 171-133 early this evening. According to AP,
Canada's three opposition parties, which control a majority in Parliament, voted against Martin's government, claiming his Liberal Party no longer has the moral authority to lead the nation.

The loss means an election for all 308 seats in the lower House of Commons, likely on Jan. 23. Martin and his Cabinet would continue to govern until then.
Canada's Liberals have spent a year on the hot seat over questions about violations of campaign finance laws and outright unlawful "kickbacks" in connection with various advertising agencies. Early this month, the so-called Gomery investigation confirmed various criminal violations, and blamed Canada's Liberal Party and various party officials, including former Prime Minister Chrétien. Recently, Paul Martin -- current Prime Minister and Liberal Party leader -- has been bribing the electorate, especially aboriginal Canadians with expensive social program give-aways, hoping to purchase a political power extension. Opposition parties claim recent Liberal proposals were leaked prior to public announcement, allowing government supporters to profit from insider trading.

Canada's famously fractured conservatives theoretically are united behind party leader Stephen Harper. Yet despite recent scandals, polls show Liberals leading Conservatives. In a land where "neoconservative" is an insult, where the Liberals won every seat in Ontario as recently as 1997, and where -- despite opting out of the Bush/Blair Coalition -- the Iraq war remains a flashpoint, Canada's center-right Conservatives are anything but a lock.

More:

Vodkapundit's Stephen Green:
I got a little schadenfreude thrill out of Martin's black eye, if only because he's been such a dipshit anti-American sometimes. But for fans of a Single Canada – like me – ditching Martin is probably nothin' but good news.

If there's anything with the ability to split Canada apart, it's Canada's Liberal Party. For years now, the LP has simultaneously flirted with Quebec Separatists while engaging in social and spending policies which constantly annoy everybody west of Winnipeg. If the LP keeps on this way, the Frenchies will eventually go their own way – and so might British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba (as a group). Poor little Ottawa, along with maybe the Maritime Provinces, would be all that remained of Rump Canada. . .

Whoever takes power after next year's election, they'll still have Bloc Québécois to deal with, if they want to form a majority. My read of BQ is, at this time they're more interested in aggrandizing their Frenchness than in making a new nation-state. Assuming BQ can make a deal with the two other non-LP parties, the new government will represent a wider range of interests than the old LP-BQ chum-fest.

Setting Sun on Lying Dems

Must read editorial in today's NY Sun:
Those who charge President Bush and Vice President Cheney with lying to get America involved in the war in Iraq, as the New York Times columnist Frank Rich did yesterday, have a special obligation to get the truth correct themselves. It's one thing for Mr. Rich to disagree with the decision to go to war in Iraq and to blame Mr. Bush and Mr. Cheney for the decision. It's another for Mr. Rich to accuse our elected leaders of misleading the country while the columnist himself goes about misleading readers of The New York Times. . .

September 11 and Iraq

Mr. Rich accuses Mr. Cheney of dissembling by conflating the terrorists of September 11, 2001, with those we are fighting in Iraq. As evidence that Mr. Cheney is lying he cites an American general who says the Iraqi insurgency is 90% homegrown. But it's undisputed that the leader of Al Qaeda in Iraq is a Jordanian, Zarqawi, who shares with the rest of Al Qaeda, including the September 11 terrorists, the goal of re-establishing the caliphate. Certainly in their violent targeting of civilians and their jihadist rhetoric, those who attacked New York office buildings on September 11 and those who are blowing up restaurants and hospitals in Iraq have a lot in common. One may choose to emphasize or de-emphasize the similarities, but emphasizing the similarities as Mr. Cheney has done hardly amounts to dissembling.

The DIA Report and Senator Levin

Mr. Rich references a report of the Defense Intelligence Agency released by Senator Levin, a Democrat of Michigan, which Mr. Rich said demolished the credibility of a source the administration used "for its false claims about Iraq-Al Qaeda collaboration." Here's how Mr. Levin hyped the report in a press release. "In February 2002, the DIA stated the following, which has remained classified until now: 'Saddam's regime is intensely secular and is wary of Islamic revolutionary movements. Moreover, Baghdad is unlikely to provide assistance to a group it cannot control.' That DIA finding is stunningly different from repeated Administration claims of a close relationship between Saddam and al-Qaeda. Just imagine the impact if that DIA conclusion had been disclosed at the time. It surely could have made a difference in the congressional vote authorizing the war."

The only stunning thing here is the disingenuousness of Messrs. Levin and Rich. First of all, the DIA report is not much different from what Bush administration officials were saying publicly at the time. On February 6, 2002, the director of Central Intelligence, George Tenet, made a similar argument in public testimony before the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, saying, "Baghdad has a long history of supporting terrorism, altering its targets to reflect changing priorities and goals. It has also had contacts with al-Qa'ida. Their ties may be limited by divergent ideologies, but the two sides' mutual antipathy toward the United States and the Saudi royal family suggests that tactical cooperation between them is possible - even though Saddam is well aware that such activity would carry serious consequences."

Moreover, the notion that the secular Baathists and the Islamic jihadists are so ideologically divergent that they will not work together has been disproven by what is going on now in Iraq, where they are cooperating against Iraqi moderates and American troops. . .

The Truth. . .

That the president spoke the truth has been sadly confirmed in free Iraq. The Associated Press's Nadia Abou El-Magd interviewed Firas Adnan, whose tongue had been cut off with a box cutter by a Saddam loyalist. Mr. Adnan, "his slurred words barely comprehensible," said of Saddam, "He is a despot, the biggest despot, Iraq will be much better without him." Susan Sachs of Mr. Rich's own New York Times reported from the mass graves of Hilla: "On April 11, 1991, a few weeks into the Shiite rebellion, Iraqi helicopters dropped leaflets over Karbala ordering everyone to leave or be attacked with chemical weapons. Mr. Mohani piled his relatives into a pickup truck and a car and fled. About four miles south of the city, the escape route was blocked. There, he said, he saw Mr. Hussein's son-in-law, Hussein Kamal, executing people randomly at a checkpoint. 'He was telling people to get out of their cars and then he would shoot them, shoot them until his arm was too tired to do it anymore.'"
There's much more; read it all.

More:

The 9/11 Commission concluded Bush did not blame the 9/11 attacks on Saddam (Chapter 10.3, footnotes omitted):
President Bush had wondered immediately after the attack whether Saddam Hussein's regime might have had a hand in it. Iraq had been an enemy of the United States for 11 years, and was the only place in the world where the United States was engaged in ongoing combat operations. As a former pilot, the President was struck by the apparent sophistication of the operation and some of the piloting, especially Hanjour's high-speed dive into the Pentagon. He told us he recalled Iraqi support for Palestinian suicide terrorists as well. Speculating about other possible states that could be involved, the President told us he also thought about Iran.

Clarke has written that on the evening of September 12, President Bush told him and some of his staff to explore possible Iraqi links to 9/11. "See if Sad-dam did this," Clarke recalls the President telling them. "See if he's linked in any way." While he believed the details of Clarke's account to be incorrect, President Bush acknowledged that he might well have spoken to Clarke at some point, asking him about Iraq.

Responding to a presidential tasking, Clarke's office sent a memo to Rice on September 18, titled "Survey of Intelligence Information on Any Iraq Involvement in the September 11 Attacks." Rice's chief staffer on Afghanistan, Zalmay Khalilzad, concurred in its conclusion that only some anecdotal evidence linked Iraq to al Qaeda. The memo found no "compelling case" that Iraq had either planned or perpetrated the attacks. It passed along a few foreign intelligence reports, including the Czech report alleging an April 2001 Prague meeting between Atta and an Iraqi intelligence officer (discussed in chapter 7) and a Polish report that personnel at the headquarters of Iraqi intelligence in Baghdad were told before September 11 to go on the streets to gauge crowd reaction to an unspecified event. Arguing that the case for links between Iraq and al Qaeda was weak, the memo pointed out that Bin Ladin resented the secularism of Saddam Hussein's regime. Finally, the memo said, there was no confirmed reporting on Saddam cooperating with Bin Ladin on unconventional weapons.

On the afternoon of 9/11, according to contemporaneous notes, Secretary Rumsfeld instructed General Myers to obtain quickly as much information as possible. The notes indicate that he also told Myers that he was not simply interested in striking empty training sites. He thought the U.S. response should consider a wide range of options and possibilities. The secretary said his instinct was to hit Saddam Hussein at the same time-not only Bin Ladin. Secretary Rumsfeld later explained that at the time, he had been considering either one of them, or perhaps someone else, as the responsible party.

According to Rice, the issue of what, if anything, to do about Iraq was really engaged at Camp David. Briefing papers on Iraq, along with many others, were in briefing materials for the participants. Rice told us the administration was concerned that Iraq would take advantage of the 9/11 attacks. She recalled that in the first Camp David session chaired by the President, Rumsfeld asked what the administration should do about Iraq. Deputy Secretary Wolfowitz made the case for striking Iraq during "this round" of the war on terrorism.

A Defense Department paper for the Camp David briefing book on the strategic concept for the war on terrorism specified three priority targets for initial action: al Qaeda, the Taliban, and Iraq. It argued that of the three, al Qaeda and Iraq posed a strategic threat to the United States. Iraq's long-standing involvement in terrorism was cited, along with its interest in weapons of mass destruction.

Secretary Powell recalled that Wolfowitz-not Rumsfeld-argued that Iraq was ultimately the source of the terrorist problem and should therefore be attacked. Powell said that Wolfowitz was not able to justify his belief that Iraq was behind 9/11. "Paul was always of the view that Iraq was a problem that had to be dealt with," Powell told us. "And he saw this as one way of using this event as a way to deal with the Iraq problem." Powell said that President Bush did not give Wolfowitz's argument "much weight." Though continuing to worry about Iraq in the following week, Powell said, President Bush saw Afghanistan as the priority.

President Bush told Bob Woodward that the decision not to invade Iraq was made at the morning session on September 15. Iraq was not even on the table during the September 15 afternoon session, which dealt solely with Afghanistan. Rice said that when President Bush called her on Sunday, September 16, he said the focus would be on Afghanistan, although he still wanted plans for Iraq should the country take some action or the administration eventually determine that it had been involved in the 9/11 attacks.

At the September 17 NSC meeting, there was some further discussion of "phase two" of the war on terrorism. President Bush ordered the Defense Department to be ready to deal with Iraq if Baghdad acted against U.S. interests, with plans to include possibly occupying Iraqi oil fields.

Within the Pentagon, Deputy Secretary Wolfowitz continued to press the case for dealing with Iraq. Writing to Rumsfeld on September 17 in a memo headlined "Preventing More Events," he argued that if there was even a 10 percent chance that Saddam Hussein was behind the 9/11 attack, maximum priority should be placed on eliminating that threat. Wolfowitz contended that the odds were "far more" than 1 in 10, citing Saddam's praise for the attack, his long record of involvement in terrorism, and theories that Ramzi Yousef was an Iraqi agent and Iraq was behind the 1993 attack on the World Trade Center. The next day, Wolfowitz renewed the argument, writing to Rumsfeld about the interest of Yousef's co-conspirator in the 1995 Manila air plot in crashing an explosives-laden plane into CIA headquarters, and about information from a foreign government regarding Iraqis' involvement in the attempted hijacking of a Gulf Air flight. Given this background, he wondered why so little thought had been devoted to the danger of suicide pilots, seeing a "failure of imagination" and a mind-set that dismissed possibilities.

On September 19, Rumsfeld offered several thoughts for his commanders as they worked on their contingency plans. Though he emphasized the worldwide nature of the conflict, the references to specific enemies or regions named only the Taliban, al Qaeda, and Afghanistan. Shelton told us the administration reviewed all the Pentagon's war plans and challenged certain assumptions underlying them, as any prudent organization or leader should do.

General Tommy Franks, the commanding general of Central Command, recalled receiving Rumsfeld's guidance that each regional commander should assess what these plans meant for his area of responsibility. He knew he would soon be striking the Taliban and al Qaeda in Afghanistan. But, he told us, he now wondered how that action was connected to what might need to be done in Somalia, Yemen, or Iraq.

On September 20, President Bush met with British Prime Minister Tony Blair, and the two leaders discussed the global conflict ahead. When Blair asked about Iraq, the President replied that Iraq was not the immediate problem. Some members of his administration, he commented, had expressed a different view, but he was the one responsible for making the decisions.

Déjà Vu All Over Again

Stop me if you've heard this before:
Sen. John Kerry initially voted in favor of a Republican-sponsored resolution calling on President Bush to explain his strategy for success in Iraq. Minutes later, the Democrat changed his vote.
No, it's not recycled news--it's the lede from a November 25, 2005, AP wire service story. A sure sign Kerry's running again in '08. As the Senator says, "Bring it on!"

(via Best of the Web)

Foreign Policy Gut-Check

Equally dizzy and bellicose, anti-war Democrats deny they're undermining anti-terrorism efforts and military morale. Americans -- even Democrats -- know that's nonsense:
Democrats fumed last week at Vice President Cheney's suggestion1 that criticism of the administration's war policies was itself becoming a hindrance to the war effort. But a new poll indicates most Americans are sympathetic to Cheney's point.

Seventy percent of people surveyed said that criticism of the war by Democratic senators hurts troop morale -- with 44 percent saying morale is hurt "a lot," according to a poll taken by RT Strategies. Even self-identified Democrats agree: 55 percent believe criticism hurts morale, while 21 percent say it helps morale.2
Since the most ardent hand-wringers supported the war before they opposed it, why are leftists whining?:
The big donors on the left want the Democrats in Congress to demand that we abandon Iraq. Most Democratic politicians aren't ready to go that far because the American public won't support what the surrender option. Some of these politicians don't want to surrender either. Others do, but are too gutless to say so, just as they were too gutless to oppose the war initially. So they attempt to pacify the left-wing base by carping about the decision to go to war, thereby avoiding the more relevant conversation about what to do going forward.

This carping serves another small purpose -- it purports to exonerate the gutless Democrats who sent our soldiers to a war they didn't really want. Although in reality they voted for the war for political purposes, by claiming that the Bush administration withheld intelligence, they can shift the blame for their cynical votes.
I agree with Peter Verkooijen's analysis: "What the Democratic party fears most is that the Bush agenda is succeeding. They desperately need to turn this into another Vietnam before it's too late." So, despite near-uniform negativity in the MSM, is "Operation Iraqi Freedom" working? Is democracy flowering (or about to) elsewhere in the mid-East?

Professor, criminologist, economist, political analyst and 2003 Medal of Freedom recipient James Q. Wilson says "yes":
Iraq has held free elections in which millions of people voted. A new, democratic constitution has been adopted that contains an extensive bill of rights. Discrimination on the basis of sex, religion or politics is banned. Soon the Iraqis will be electing their first parliament.

An independent judiciary exists, almost all public schools are open, every hospital is functioning, and oil sales have increased sharply. In most parts of the country, people move about freely and safely.

According to surveys, Iraqis are overwhelmingly opposed to the use of violence to achieve political ends, and the great majority believe that their lives will improve in the future. The Iraqi economy is growing very rapidly, much more rapidly than the inflation rate.

In some places, the terrorists who lost the war are now fighting back by killing Iraqi civilians. Some brave American soldiers have also been killed, but most of the attacks are directed at decent, honest Iraqis. This is not a civil war; it is terrorism gone mad.

And the terrorists have failed. They could not stop free elections. They could not prevent Iraqi leaders from taking office. They could not close the schools or hospitals. They could not prevent the emergence of a vigorous free press that now involves over 170 newspapers that represent every shade of opinion.

Terrorist leaders such as Zarqawi have lost. Most Sunni leaders, whom Zarqawi was hoping to mobilize, have rejected his call to defeat any constitution. The Muslims in his hometown in Jordan have denounced him. Despite his murderous efforts, candidates representing every legitimate point of view and every ethnic background are competing for office in the new Iraqi government.
Iraqis are optimistic--far more so than U.S. lefties or anti-Bush (i.e., most) journalists, as Strategy Page's James Dunnigan repeatedly has observed:
The fighting in Iraq is constantly misreported as an “insurgency,” evoking images of Vietnam or World War II guerillas. In actuality, the fighting is the attempt by Saddam’s enforcers to hold off their encounter with a democratic Iraq’s application of punishments for past crimes. Saddam’s army was defeated, but his secret police and enforcers went home and kept fighting. Saddam’s people believe that they have a choice between getting back control of the country, or suffering prison, or worse, for old sins. But for complex political reasons, the media lovingly depicts these murderous thugs as brave freedom fighters. It’s generally ignored that nearly all the violence is occurring in areas dominated by Sunni Arabs, who are but 20 percent of the population. Kurdish and Shia Arab areas are quiet. Calling this fighting a civil war is being generous, as one could make a case for it simply being a case of organized crime writ large. It’s gangbusters, not guerillas. . .

[But f]ew reporters in Iraq speak Arabic, or know much about Iraqi history or how military operations work. This means much reporting is flawed and misleading. To make matters worse, news editors outside Iraq often decide what stories to pursue, more concerned with what they, or the audience back home, wants to see, rather than what is actually happening in Iraq.
Max Boot agrees:
When it comes to the future of Iraq, there is a deep disconnect between those who have firsthand knowledge of the situation — Iraqis and U.S. soldiers serving in Iraq — and those whose impressions are shaped by doomsday press coverage and the imperatives of domestic politics. . .

Yet in a survey last month from the U.S.-based International Republican Institute, 47% of Iraqis polled said their country was headed in the right direction, as opposed to 37% who said they thought that it was going in the wrong direction. And 56% thought things would be better in six months. Only 16% thought they would be worse.
(The IRI poll of November 11th shows 49 % "right direction" compared to 36 % "wrong direction.")

As Publius Pundit's Kirk Sowell explains, the recently concluded Cairo conference on Iraqi "national reconciliation" -- attended by Kurds, Sunnis and Shias -- provides new evidence the Iraqi government and major interest groups side with the U.S./U.K. coalition; the conference:
rejected wording sought by Sunnis which would have explicitly sanctioned “resistance… in the shadow of the occupation.” Moreover, statements from leading Shia officials made clear that they interpreted the Iraqi “resistance” to be the current government and its fight against the insurgents. . .

Prime Minister Jaafari . . . mocked insurgents who called themselves “resistance” by asking rhetorically “where was this resistance” during the time of Saddam Hussein? “The resistance, they are now the leaders of the country.” This last statement was a veiled reference to the fact that Jaafari’s group had opposed Saddam and had been forced to leave the country, suggesting that they, once in resistance outside, had now returned to lead.
Indeed, looking at the mid-East as a whole, even long-standing pessimists are optimistic, according to the Washington Post's Jim Hoagland:
In Egypt, Hosni Mubarak -- who once told an American diplomat that democratic reforms were a good concept but would not happen while he ruled -- is haltingly and spitefully letting his system become more open as pressure for democratic change spreads in other Arab lands.

A significant terrorist attack in Israel or a sudden whim by Egypt's aging autocrat could stymie the reversals I cite. Yes, it is still the Middle East.

"But it is a Middle East in which those who believe in democracy and civil society are finally actors, even though we still face big obstacles," says Saad Eddin Ibrahim, Egypt's battle-scarred democratic activist.

Ibrahim originally opposed the invasion of Iraq. But it "has unfrozen the Middle East, just as Napoleon's 1798 expedition did. Elections in Iraq force the theocrats and autocrats to put democracy on the agenda, even if only to fight against us. Look, neither Napoleon nor President Bush could impregnate the region with political change. But they were able to be the midwives," Ibrahim told me in Washington.

Egypt has allowed nongovernmental organizations to monitor local elections this month, and it is permitting more freedom of expression in a handful of independent newspapers recently established there. "The regime still cheats in elections but less than before," said Ibrahim, to explain his relative optimism.
And, mirabile dictu -- thanks to the unfairly scorned John Bolton -- even the UN shows promise: for the first time, the UN condemned Hizbullah:
Following intense US pressure, the United Nations Security Council on Wednesday issued an unprecedented condemnation of Monday's Hizbullah attacks on northern Israel.

This condemnation - slamming Hizbullah by name for "acts of hatred" - marked the first time the Security Council has ever reprimanded Hizbullah for cross-border attacks on Israel. The condemnation followed by two days a failed attempt to get a condemnation issued on Monday, the day of the attack, when Algeria came out against any mention of Hizbullah in the statement.

When asked what changed from Monday to Wednesday, one diplomatic official replied: "John Bolton," a reference to the US ambassador to the UN. Bolton lobbied vigorously for the passage of the statement.
And on the homefront? Ignore the Dems; listen to Jane Kenny, in her letter to the editor of USA Today:
Why hasn't this country been attacked since 9/11? Think about it: It has been four years. It sure looks like President Bush's war strategy — "the best defense is a good offense" — is very effective ("American attitudes on Iraq similar to those in Vietnam," Cover story, News, Wednesday).

There's one thing we have to give Bush credit for: He's consistent. The president has maintained that we will stay the course, continue to pursue the terrorists and defeat them across the globe so we won't have to fight them here.

The president's critics need to look at the big picture. Bush has the ultimate responsibility to protect the homeland, and on that issue he is consistent, unwavering and courageous — even when his popularity ebbs in the polls and the press continues to pound him.
While the left's still locked into mid-East "mirror imaging", reflexive pro-Frogism, biasing High Schoolers against Bush, fuzzy math and forging alliances with space aliens, the President's doing well to stay the course. Call it a "B+".

More:

Today's Christian Science Monitor:
[T]he Iraq of Corporal Mayer's memory is not solely a place of death and loss. It is also a place of hope. It is the hope of the town of Hit, which he saw transform from an insurgent stronghold to a place where kids played on Marine trucks. It is the hope of villagers who whispered where roadside bombs were hidden. But most of all, it is the hope he saw in a young Iraqi girl who loved pens and Oreo cookies.

Like many soldiers and marines returning from Iraq, Mayer looks at the bleak portrayal of the war at home with perplexity - if not annoyance. It is a perception gap that has put the military and media at odds, as troops complain that the media care only about death tolls, while the media counter that their job is to look at the broader picture, not through the soda straw of troops' individual experiences.
The November 26th Economist:
Every reasonable person should be able to agree on two things about America's presence in Iraq. First, if the Iraqi government formally asks the troops to leave, they should do so. Second, the argument about whether America should quit Iraq is not the same as the one about whether it should have gone there in the first place. It must be about the future.
Still More:

Mary Laney in the Chicago Sun-Times:
[H]ere we get all the static, all the talking heads, and all the theories of what's happening over there. We hear politics instead of facts. We get editorials in place of reports. We have Congress tied up with some politicians making threats and insisting that we set a date to withdraw our troops or withdraw our troops immediately. We hear them making accusations that President Bush lied when he said Saddam had weapons of mass destruction -- even though former President Bill Clinton said the same thing when he was in office, as did others in his party who now seem to be suffering from an acute case of amnesia regarding the recent past.

The supreme ayatollah of Iran is urging a speedy pullout of foreign troops from Iraq. Now, if former President Jimmy Carter were still in the White House, perhaps that would happen.
More x More x More:

SGT Ron Long:
If you want to know if progress is being made in Iraq, I can tell you, "YES." As the Medic on the MTT (Military Training Team), I was personally involved in the training of hundreds of Iraqi Army troops (and some Iraqi Police).

The vast majority of the Iraqi Security Forces that we trained are dedicated and want to learn as much as they can so that they can soon take over the security and stability of their new, free nation. This process takes time though, a fact that some people cannot understand. They cannot just transform overnight. It will take months and even years to do this.
More Still:

SGT Walter J. Rausch, 1st Platoon, 101st Airborne Division (Air Assault):
You need not to have a great understanding of the world but rather common sense to realize that it is our duty as HUMAN BEINGS to free the oppressed. If you lived that way would you not want someone to help you????

The Iraqi’s pour into the streets to wave at us and when we liberated the cities during the war they gathered in the thousands to cheer, hug and kiss us. It was what the soldier’s in WW2 experienced, yet no one questioned their cause!! Saddam was no better than Hitler! He tortured and killed thousands of innocent people. We are heroes over here, yet American’s badmouth our President for having us here.

Every police station here has a dozen or more memorials for officers that were murdered trying to ensure that their people live free. These are husbands, fathers, and sons killed every day. What if it were your country? What would your choice be? Everything we fight for is worth the blood that may be shed. The media never reports the true HEROISM I witness everyday in the Iraqi’s. Yes there are bad one’s here, but I assure you they are a minuscule percent.
Interesting analysis by Alaa at the Messopotamian:
[T]he fury of the Arabs and other Moslems against the Americans is not because they invaded and occupied Iraq, but because as a result of this action and the fall of the Saddam regime, the Shiaas have become liberated and acquired a louder voice. This by the way is also the main factor fanning the “insurrection” and terrorism in Iraq, a fact which is publicly proclaimed by people like Zarqawi. Thus the development of representative democracy with the Iraqi Sunnis taking their rightful place is the real antidote to these stupid prejudices. This is the hope of all patriotic Iraqis of all sects and the final happy outcome that we are all praying and working for.
__________________

1 Assuming anyone watching CNN could identify Vice President Cheney.

2 Commenting on LGF, photo-blogger Zombie digs deeper:
[T]he pdf file of the actual poll results . . . says that 70% thought the Dems were hurting morale, 13% thought they were helping morale, and 17% refused to answer. How much do you want to bet that a large percentage of that 17% were far lefties who were insulted by the question, that their whole point was to hurt morale, but they didn't want to say that to the pollster?
(via LGF, Instapundit, MaxedOutMama, Joe's Dartblog, Protein Wisdom, SC&A and The Anchoress)

Monday, November 21, 2005

Peace = War

The pro-terrorist cabal just gained a new conspirator--counter-culture author Kurt Vonnegut:
[D]iscussing his views with The Weekend Australian, Vonnegut said it was "sweet and honourable" to die for what you believe in, and rejected the idea that terrorists were motivated by twisted religious beliefs.

"They are dying for their own self-respect," he said. "It's a terrible thing to deprive someone of their self-respect. It's like your culture is nothing, your race is nothing, you're nothing."

Asked if he thought of terrorists as soldiers, Vonnegut, a decorated World War II veteran, said: "I regard them as very brave people, yes."

He equated the actions of suicide bombers with US president Harry Truman's 1945 decision to drop the atomic bomb on Hiroshima.

On the Iraq war, he said: "What George Bush and his gang did not realise was that people fight back."

Vonnegut suggested suicide bombers must feel an "amazing high". He said: "You would know death is going to be painless, so the anticipation - it must be an amazing high."

Vonnegut's comments are sharply at odds with his reputation as a peace activist and his distinguished war service.
Proving again they're not anti-war; they just hate the United States. Under the banner of peace and pacifism, they cheer the enemy and wish us dead. Mere critique isn't the question; and they're well past appeasement. Rather, Vonnegut joins Code Pink, Ted Rall and Michael Moore as unpatriotic and anti-American.

More:

Michael Yon's got photos of Iraqis gone missing from the MSM.

(via Best of the Web, My Vast Right Wing Conspiracy)

Good News for Paris Hilton

Using a hidden video camera, high school student Jason Smith secretly taped consensual sexual relations with his girlfriend, a student at the same school. After the pair split, Smith circulated copies to classmates by email. The ex sued anonymously, seeking damages for invasion of privacy under 18 U.S.C. § 2511(a), covering anyone who "intentionally intercepts, endeavors to intercept, or procures any other person to intercept or endeavor to intercept, any wire, oral, or electronic communication." The trial judge concluded taping wasn't an "interception," and dismissed the suit.

That decision was reversed today (Doe v. Smith, No. 05-1903 (7th Cir. Nov. 21, 2005)), in an opinion written by Judge Frank Easterbrook for a unanimous three judge panel. The court reasoned voyeuristic video intercepted. . . well, something:
This defined term “means the aural or other acquisition of the contents of any wire, electronic, or oral communication through the use of any electronic, mechanical, or other device.” 18 U.S.C. § 2510(4). If Doe and Smith engaged in “oral communication” in Smith’s bedroom, then its acquisition by a video recorder—an “electronic . . . device”—is covered.
Easterbrook also directed the district judge on remand to "revisit the question whether the plaintiff should be allowed to proceed anonymously. The judge granted her application to do so without discussing this circuit’s decisions, which disfavor anonymous litigation." However, as Howard Bashman discovered, "Doe's" own lawyer blew his client's cover in his Rule 26.1 Statement. Bashman observes:
[I]t is worth pondering who bears responsibility when an electronically-filed document (such as the Brief for Appellant in this case) reveals the identity of the appellant proceeding under a court-approved pseudonym and the document is posted, in unredacted form, online at the federal appellate court's website.
Translation: whether or not "Doe" recovers from Smith, she's got a second shot--for invasion of privacy (and malpractice) by her lawyer.

Demonizing DeLay

Former Federal Election Commission Chair Bradley Smith explains why the Dems' Tom DeLay witch-hunt will fail (today's WSJ, subscription only):
Here are the basic facts: Texans for a Republican Majority (TRMPAC) is a political action committee which Mr. DeLay helped organize. According to the indictments, in September 2002 six corporations contributed $155,000 to TRMPAC, which then contributed $190,000 to the Republican National State Elections Committee (RNSEC -- an arm of the Republican National Committee). The RNSEC later contributed $190,000 to seven candidates for the Texas House of Representatives. The indictment claims that is "money laundering" by Mr. DeLay and his associates, since Texas law prohibits corporate donations to state political campaigns. And much has been made of the fact that Mr. Earle attached to the indictment a copy of TRMPAC's check to the RNSEC -- as if it were damning evidence uncovered after thorough investigation.

That is hardly the case: The contribution is readily available public information, reported by the RNSEC in its 2002 monthly reports to the Federal Election Commission. So what is going on? Here we need to take a step back and look at federal law as it existed before the McCain-Feingold campaign finance legislation, which took effect in November 2002 -- after the contributions named in Mr. Earle's indictment.

The place to begin is with national political parties, which raise money in all 50 states and spend money supporting state and local candidates in all 50 states. Before McCain-Feingold, both the Republican and the Democratic parties routinely accepted "soft money" (from corporations and unions, plus large individual contributions) from Texas and other states where corporate funds could not be contributed to candidates. National parties were free to spend soft money on party administration, advertising on issues of importance to the party, and also to send it back to state and local candidates in the more than 20 states that allow corporate contributions. At the same time, national parties also received contributions of "hard money," consisting of smaller individual contributions. Hard money, kept in separate accounts, was also sent back to state candidates -- in all states.

There was thus a constant flow of hard and soft money (the latter including corporate contributions) to the national party committees, some of which was sent back to state candidates. Indeed, during the 1990s the DNC developed a "tally" system in part to see that soft money contributed to the DNC from a given state was roughly offset by the hard money contributions from the DNC in that state.

Before McCain-Feingold, no state, to my knowledge, had ever held that this practice violated laws against corporate contributions to candidates. No one considered a common practice such as this to be "money laundering" any more than you would think that you and your bank had conspired to "launder" money when you deposited your paycheck in the bank, and the bank later loaned you money to buy a car. . .

To summarize, the theory against Mr. DeLay goes something like this: Corporations made legal contributions to TRMPAC; and then TRMPAC made a legal contribution of this soft money to the RNSEC, which, as required by federal law, kept the funds in a separate account. The RNSEC then used an account containing individual contributions (hard money) to make otherwise legal contributions to 42 candidates for state or local office in Texas, including seven who may have been specifically recommended to them by Mr. DeLay and others. Somehow this series of legal transactions constitutes money laundering.

Two questions result. First, is it "laundering" when the law specifically allows corporate contributions to be used for administrative costs, and a party or PAC uses individual contributions thereby freed up to make increased candidate contributions? Second, even if so, in light of the unprosecuted and public ubiquity of the practice, on both state and federal levels, is it consistent with basic due process to now charge Mr. DeLay and his associates with a crime for which the possible penalties include life imprisonment?
DeLay did nothing unlawful--unless the lefty campaign to criminalize conservatism succeeds.

Scenes from a Blue State

Kate Thornton Buzicky is a student at Harvard Law School. Unusually, she's also a First Lieutenant in the United States Army, thus qualifying for the endangered species list:
At places like Harvard, the military is a rarity on campus. One January morning last year, I was sitting outside a classroom with some classmates waiting for our Civil Procedure exam to begin. A male student stopped to greet us. He was wearing a puffy vest over what looked like. an old version of the Army physical training sweatshirt--the oatmeal gray cotton zip-up. I asked him if it was an Army sweatshirt (the vest covered his chest where the "ARMY" logo would be). "No way," he scoffed. "I would never wear that. I hate the Army."

"Oh," I replied, "I am in the Army." He looked at me as if I had announced I had three legs and was born on Neptune. "You? In the Army?" He started to laugh, as if I were making a joke. But when I offered to show him my military ID card as proof he finally seemed to believe me.
As a result, Ms. Buzicky's on the front line of phony liberal tolerance:
I am proud to serve, and I am proud to put my beliefs aside when duty requires it; many civilians don't seem able to understand this.

Service is an everyday thing; it means that an individual regularly sacrifices for the good of the whole. Sometimes that sacrifice is trivial (maybe I would like to wear bigger pearl earrings with those Class As, but I don't) and sometimes it is serious, such as complying with the regulations that govern political activity among Army Officers. In both situations, soldiers forgo a privilege in the name of a bigger purpose--serving their fellow citizens.

I never ask that my fellow liberals agree with me, just that they respect my sense of obligation and professional duty. But at Harvard, that's a tough sell. Here, the emphasis is on the individual--the "me", the "I," and the "mine." It is difficult to explain a group obligation to people who idolize the first person singular.

But the most difficult part of the recruiting period has been learning the limits of liberal tolerance. It has been uncomfortable to see that the lessons I learned from the traditional liberal platform appear not to apply to me.
In liberal strong-holds from Cambridge Massachusetts to Cambridge England, tolerance "is a lighter yoke when one excludes adversaries from the start--and tolerate only those with whom one already agrees."

Sunday, November 20, 2005

More Middle-East Karaoke

Last month, I highlighted Britain's Royal Dragoon Guard (based in Al Faw in southern Iraq) performing Show Me the Way To Amarillo, written years ago by Neil Sedaka but a recent surprise U.K. hit when comedian Peter Kay used Tony Christie's version in his latest video.

Not to be out-done, Dutch troops in Afghanistan did a copy-cat Amarillo. But the "senior service" retaliated: Don't miss copious "air guitar" as the Royal Navy rhapsodizes Bohemia, all five minutes fifty seconds of it.

More:

A bit off topic, but check out two Chinese students in their dorm lip-syncing to the Backstreet Boys.

(via reader Doug J. and The Corner)

Press Bias # LXIV

The essence of unfair bias is treating similarly situated persons differently. See Melody Music v. F.C.C., 345 F.2d 730, 732 (D.C. Cir. 1965). The media flunks that criterion, repeatedly guilty of coming in like a lion for Republicans and conservatives but likening liberal Democrats to lambs. Today's example was penned by professors Lee Epstein and Jeffrey Segal, authors of Advice and Consent: The Politics of Judicial Appointments. Their lead story in the Washington Post's "Opinion" section, about the predicting Supreme Court votes based on the ideology or "label" of each Justice, dispels any doubt about their distortions:
As it turns out, those labels often convey useful information about how nominees, upon ascending to the high court, approach the cases before them. At the time of Scalia's nomination in 1986, virtually all the commentary -- on the left and the right -- predicted that he would be quite conservative. That forecast proved accurate. Scalia now reaches right-of-center decisions in almost seven out of every 10 cases he considers. Likewise, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, assessed as moderate-to-liberal when she was picked in 1993, votes precisely as that label would suggest, reaching liberal outcomes in about two-thirds of the court's cases.
Got that? Voting to the "right" almost 70 percent of the time is "quite conservative." By contrast, a Justice who votes "left" in "about" 67 percent of the cases is "moderate-to-liberal." What a difference 3 percent makes when comparing Scalia and Ginsburg.

I pity the fool who reads only the MSM.

All Arabs Aren't America's Enemies

Good news from Amman Jordan:
At least 200,000 persons demonstrated yesterday against the recent bombings of three luxury hotels, while a new online statement attributed to terrorist leader Abu Musab Zarqawi defended the attacks and threatened to cut off the head of Jordan's King Abdullah II.

An anti-terrorist demonstration of such size is unprecedented in the Arab world, where Zarqawi, his mentor, Osama bin Laden, and their al Qaeda organization have attained folk-hero status among Muslim masses.

"Zarqawi, from Amman, we say to you: 'You are a coward,'" protesters chanted while brandishing banners with the names of their tribes from every part of Jordan.
Battling terrorists, one at a time, will beat terrorism. Jordanians understand; too bad Dems don't.

(via LGF)