Wednesday, May 09, 2007

Neo-Con in a Nutshell

Victor Davis Hanson two weeks ago:
There are dozens of tragic ironies in Iraq. The fostering of democracy by a Republican president only alienated his dour realist base. Yet his idealism did not even win as recompense faint sympathy from supposedly Wilsonian Democratic opponents. Indeed, they now sound like Bob Taft isolationists. The fiercest critics of the brave struggling Iraqi elected government remain liberal Senate Democrats, not Republicans. . .

We are embarking on this new course in the hopes that the American lives sacrificed and our treasure spent are for a friendly people that appreciates our efforts. I think they do, and that the record of brave Iraqi reformers is worth the effort -- both for the sake of our future security and so as to adopt a new moral posture that respects Arab self-determination. . .

[But] we need more clarity both here and abroad. First, the administration must articulate how our idealism is stark realism as well. Americans daily have to be reminded that consensual government in Iraq -- not just plebiscites -- is in our long-term strategic interest. Second, we should hear far more of Iraqi cooperation and joint operations, both military and civilian, that in fact do characterize this war and reveal an Arab desire to be free of the past. And third, far more long-suffering members of the Iraqi government need to express some appreciation for the American sacrifice -- and express such gratitude to the American people directly.

1 comment:

Cogito Sometimes said...

Welcome Back Carl!

I like your 5/9/2007 post, especially the last sentence. I have been wondering why he haven’t heard more from the Iraqi government . . . or the Iraqi citizens. Perhaps it is because they can’t speak out for fear of reprisals, which may be part of the problem there. It might help significantly if there were some way to obtain an independent, unbiased, and statistically valid poll or vote (that might offer protective anonymity) to let us know exactly what the Iraqi citizens think of the U.S. involvement and how they would like it to proceed in assisting their country. If there are some, please post them. If nothing else, a positive result might help boost the morale and commitment of the (not only U.S.) men and women risking their lives in Iraq on a daily basis, their families and friends who worry about them on a daily basis, and those interested in achieving a world of peace and justice not only for us, but also for future generations, no matter what the cultural, ideological or religious differences.