Once again, decency is a hot topic on the Hill and at the FCC. Too bad it's mostly a waste of time. Don't get me wrong--the obscene and indecent have no place on entertainment designed for, or habitually seen by, minors. But the Supreme Court properly held that defining obscenity by reference to minors would "reduce the adult population . . . to reading only what is fit for children. . . Surely, this is to burn the house to roast the pig." And today, with "channel lockout" technology available on both cable and satellite, and a lessened concern outside of free over-the-air broadcasting, much of the debate is silly and moot.
I've a professional interest in the question -- and expect to be immersed starting January 1st when keeping Howard Stern on the air becomes part of my responsibilities. Still, I'd like to think my work hasn't biased my opinion. And I'd also like to think mine the conservative position on decency. Anyone agree?
Aristotle-to-Ricardo-to-Hayek turn the double play way better than Plato-to-Rousseau-to-Rawls
Friday, November 18, 2005
Thursday, November 17, 2005
Sunrise, Sunset/Swiftly Flow the Blogs
Hassan at the fictional, but informative, An Average Iraqi blog tallied the start-up and fade-out of Iraqi blogs between statue down and Constitution up. "Where is Raed" was the first, starting in June 2003--it went dark only seven months later on December 8th. On New Years day 2003, only two blogs were authored by Iraqis in Iraq. According to Hassan, by New Years Eve, there were:
As of November 11th, blogs still are booming:
22 Iraqi bloggers on the web. [Today,] only 15 of them still blogging, while most of the others quit a long time ago.There were 66 Iraqi blogs at the end of 2004; only 37 survive.
As of November 11th, blogs still are booming:
Year 2005 has witnessed 46 new Iraqi bloggers so far. Right now 22 of them are still blogging. The total sum of the Iraqi bloggers to join the blogosphere since Pax first signed in on June 2002 is 112, of those there are only 59 active right now.Unrelated to the foregoing, Haneen's Photo from Iraq blog contains pix of Baghdad over the past three months.
Another Dem With WMD Amnesia
Item -- Former President Bill Clinton, Tuesday November 15, 2005:
More:
Item -- Senator John Kerry today: "It is hard to name a government official with less credibility on Iraq than Vice-President Cheney."
Item -- Senator John Kerry October 9, 2002:
Clintons Announce Opposition to Iraq WarItem -- President Bill Clinton, December 16, 1998:
In twin moves that amount to a 180 degree reversal of their previous positions, former President Bill Clinton called the Iraq war yesterday "a big mistake," while his wife, Sen. Hillary Clinton, voted for a Democratic bill that would announce a timetable for U.S. withdrawal.
"Saddam is gone. It's a good thing, but I don't agree with what was done," Mr. Clinton told students at the American University of Dubai.
"It was a big mistake," he added, in quotes picked up by the Associated Press. "The American government made several errors, one of which is how easy it would be to get rid of Saddam and how hard it would be to unite the country."
Six weeks ago, Saddam Hussein announced that he would no longer cooperate with the United Nations weapons inspectors called UNSCOM. They are highly professional experts from dozens of countries. Their job is to oversee the elimination of Iraq’s capability to retain, create and use weapons of mass destruction, and to verify that Iraq does not attempt to rebuild that capability. The inspectors undertook this mission first 7 1/2 years ago at the end of the Gulf War when Iraq agreed to declare and destroy its arsenal as a condition of the ceasefire.Video of entire 1998 speech here.
The international community had good reason to set this requirement. Other countries possess weapons of mass destruction and ballistic missiles. With Saddam, there is one big difference: He has used them. Not once, but repeatedly. Unleashing chemical weapons against Iranian troops during a decade-long war. Not only against soldiers, but against civilians, firing Scud missiles at the citizens of Israel, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain and Iran. And not only against a foreign enemy, but even against his own people, gassing Kurdish civilians in Northern Iraq.
The international community had little doubt then, and I have no doubt today, that left unchecked, Saddam Hussein will use these terrible weapons again.
More:
Item -- Senator John Kerry today: "It is hard to name a government official with less credibility on Iraq than Vice-President Cheney."
Item -- Senator John Kerry October 9, 2002:
There are legitimate questions about that timing. But none of the underlying realities of the threat, none of the underlying realities of the choices we face are altered because they are, in fact, the same as they were in 1991 when we discovered those weapons when the teams went in, and in 1998 when the teams were kicked out.(via The Political Teen, California Conservative, In the Right Place and the Jerusalem Post)
With respect to Saddam Hussein and the threat he presents, we must ask ourselves a simple question: Why? Why is Saddam Hussein pursuing weapons that most nations have agreed to limit or give up? Why is Saddam Hussein guilty of breaking his own cease-fire agreement with the international community? Why is Saddam Hussein attempting to develop nuclear weapons when most nations don't even try, and responsible nations that have them attempt to limit their potential for disaster? Why did Saddam Hussein threaten and provoke? Why does he develop missiles that exceed allowable limits? Why did Saddam Hussein lie and deceive the inspection teams previously? Why did Saddam Hussein not account for all of the weapons of mass destruction which UNSCOM identified? Why is he seeking to develop unmanned airborne vehicles for delivery of biological agents?
Does he do all of these things because he wants to live by international standards of behavior? Because he respects international law? Because he is a nice guy underneath it all and the world should trust him?
It would be naive to the point of grave danger not to believe that, left to his own devices, Saddam Hussein will provoke, misjudge, or stumble into a future, more dangerous confrontation with the civilized world. He has as much as promised it. He has already created a stunning track record of miscalculation. He miscalculated an 8-year war with Iran. He miscalculated the invasion of Kuwait. He miscalculated America's responses to it. He miscalculated the result of setting oil rigs on fire. He miscalculated the impact of sending Scuds into Israel. He miscalculated his own military might. He miscalculated the Arab world's response to his plight. He miscalculated in attempting an assassination of a former President of the United States. And he is miscalculating now America's judgments about his miscalculations.
All those miscalculations are compounded by the rest of history. A brutal, oppressive dictator, guilty of personally murdering and condoning murder and torture, grotesque violence against women, execution of political opponents, a war criminal who used chemical weapons against another nation and, of course, as we know, against his own people, the Kurds. He has diverted funds from the Oil-for-Food program, intended by the international community to go to his own people. He has supported and harbored terrorist groups, particularly radical Palestinian groups such as Abu Nidal, and he has given money to families of suicide murderers in Israel.
Wednesday, November 16, 2005
Law Suit of the Week
It's come to this:
But because abortion is lawful, under at least some circumstances, in all eight Australian states/territories, are doctors liable to the unborn? Harriton's lawyer, B.W. Walker, addressed that question in last Thursday's argument before the High Court of Australia:
Whatever one's view on abortion, the notion of "wrongful life" is depressing. As Right Wing News' John Hawkins says:
An Australian woman who is deaf, blind and physically and mentally disabled wants to sue the doctor who allowed her to be born.According to Court TV:
Lawyers for Alexia Harriton, 24, who needs round-the-clock care, made the application yesterday to the Australian High Court, arguing that her mother's doctor was negligent in failing to diagnose rubella infection early in the pregnancy.
Harriton, 24, is seeking compensation from the doctor who misdiagnosed rubella in the first trimester of her mother's pregnancy, claiming Olga Harriton would have aborted her had she been aware of the potential birth defects arising from the illness.Causation? Harriton insists 'I don't have to show you any stinking' causation, says Perry DeHavilland at Samizdata: "Never mind that rubella during pregnancy does not guarantee what happened to Ms. Harriton."
But because abortion is lawful, under at least some circumstances, in all eight Australian states/territories, are doctors liable to the unborn? Harriton's lawyer, B.W. Walker, addressed that question in last Thursday's argument before the High Court of Australia:
How can one have before a person exists a duty owed to the person, let alone a breach of that duty? How can one have before a person exists damage suffered by that person following, that is as a result of, that pre-existing duty, that pre-existing breach. The law, for obvious reasons to do with ultimately our biology and appropriate social standards, would not have a bar of such logic standing in the way of the claim. How, after all, could it be truly said that the law saying you cannot be a person, thus you cannot have a cause of action until you are born, how could the law tolerate doctors who make their living by looking after pregnant women and their embryos saying, “I have no duty to take into account that I may by my negligence damage the embryo” and not only people who know of or have been engaged in the interest of the embryo, but also doctors who are dealing with women who may or may not be pregnant.What about "standing?" I hear you say. Justice Kirby asked the same question:
KIRBY J: At least one theoretical argument for not [allowing such lawsuits] is then do we have actions on behalf of embryos which were not permitted to come to full term or which were aborted for the loss of the chance of life?And damages? What are the damages from "wrongful birth?" Two answers. First:
MR WALKER: No. There would be no person to sue.
KIRBY J: Well, there might be somebody who wished to sue on their behalf – a parent who did not agree with the termination.
MR WALKER: Your Honour, that is another case. It is not - - -
KIRBY J: I am just testing the logic of it.
MR WALKER: Your Honour, I must not resist the consequentialist testing, and I do not resist that as a notion. I simply say that particular consequence, that there are several steps to be gone through before one would ever get to a suit in the name of, or . . . on account of a person who was never born.
Lawyers for the Sydney woman argued in Australia's highest court Thursday that Dr. Paul Stephens is liable for the costs arising from a lifetime of medical treatment that Harriton needs to survive.But Mr. Walker wants more:
HEYDON J: Do you claim lost earnings?Apparently the United States isn't the only country in desperate need of tort reform--Steven Den Beste notes "'Wrongful Life' lawsuits have become far more common than you may realize."
MR WALKER: Your Honour, yes. . . It is the particular physical condition not of being alive but what I have summed-up in the word “disability” as a - - -
GLEESON CJ: As compared with what?
MR WALKER: As compared with not having been born.
Whatever one's view on abortion, the notion of "wrongful life" is depressing. As Right Wing News' John Hawkins says:
[L]ife is always better than death in a case like this and once you decide that it isn't, you've taken the first step down the road towards eugenics. If Alexa is better off dead than alive because of her disabilities, then the next logical question is in what other cases is the child better off being murdered in the womb? What if the child is just retarded? What about crippled? Heck, what about a child with a harelip or a clubfoot? Are they such abominations that they deserve to be ripped to pieces by an abortionist rather than allowed to live?
Dems Fight WMD Amnesia
Can the lying, over-partisan opposition regain America's trust? Jeff Goldstein offers Nine rejected Democratic talking points for why Congressional Dems initially believed Chimpy McHitlerburton's WMD Intelligence LIES. Here's numbers nine, three and two:
9. Three words: “Andrew Card: Illuminati.” Now please, no more questions. They’re everywhere. . .
3. Have you ever seen how thick some of those intelligence reports are? Who has time to read all that—particularly when they drop it on us so close to happy hour?
2. NONE OF YOUR GODDAMNED BUSINESS, WARMONGERS!
Speech of the Week
Floor Statement of Senator Joe Lieberman on Iraq Amendments to the FY06 Defense Authorization Bill:
I am grateful to the American military for the extraordinary bravery and brilliance of their campaign to remove Saddam Hussein. I know we are safer as a nation, and to say the obvious that the Iraqi people are freer as a people, and the Middle East has a chance for a new day and stability with Saddam Hussein gone. . .
The international intelligence community believed Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction. Probably most significant, and I guess historically puzzling, is that Saddam Hussein acted in a way to send a message that he had a program of weapons of mass destruction. He would not, in response to one of the 17 U.N. Security Council resolutions that he violated, declare he had eliminated the inventory of weapons of mass destruction that he reported to the U.N. after the end of the gulf war in 1991. . .
I want to say that the debate about the war has become much too partisan in our time. And something is happening here tonight that I believe, I hope, I pray we will look back and say was a turning point and opened the road to Republican and Democratic cooperation, White House and congressional cooperation, to complete the mission. As Senator Levin said, no matter what anyone thinks about why we got into the war and whether we should have been in there, it is hard to find anybody around the Senate – I have not heard anybody – who does not want us to successfully complete our mission there. I feel that deeply.
If we withdraw prematurely from Iraq, there will be civil war, and there is a great probability that others in the neighborhood will come in. The Iranians will be tempted to come in on the side of the Shia Muslims in the south. The Turks will be tempted to come in against the Kurds in the north. The other Sunni nations, such as the Saudis and the Jordanians, will be sorely tempted, if not to come in at least to aggressively support the Sunni Muslim population. There will be instability in the Middle East, and the hope of creating a different model for a better life in the Middle East in this historic center of the Arab world, Iraq, will be gone.
If we successfully complete our mission, we will have left a country that is self-governing with an open economy, with an opportunity for the people of Iraq to do what they clearly want to do, which is to live a better life, to get a job, to have their kids get a decent education, to live a better life. There seems to be broad consensus on that, and yet the partisanship that characterizes our time here gets in the way of realizing those broadly expressed and shared goals.
“Politics must end at the water's edge.” That is what Senator Arthur Vandenberg of Michigan said, articulating the important ideal that we seem to have lost too often in our time. I found a fuller statement of Senator Vandenberg’s position, the ideal. I found it to be in some ways more complicated and in other ways much more compelling. I want to read from it. Senator Vandenberg said:To me ‘bipartisan foreign policy’ means a mutual effort, under our indispensable two-party system, to unite our official voice at the water's edge so that America speaks with maximum authority against those who would divide and conquer us and the free world.That speaks to us today – the threat of Islamist terrorism, the desire they have to divide us and, in that sense, to conquer us in the free world. Senator Vandenberg continued in his definition of what he meant by bipartisanship in foreign policy:It does not involve the remotest surrender of free debate in determining our position. On the contrary, frank cooperation and free debate are indispensable to ultimate unity of which I speak.In a word, it simply seeks national security ahead of partisan advantage.
I felt again in recent days and recent months how far we have strayed down the partisan path from Vandenberg's ideals. . .
The questions raised about prewar intelligence are not irrelevant, they are not unimportant, but they are nowhere near as important and relevant as how we successfully complete our mission in Iraq and protect the 150,000 men and women in uniform who are fighting for us there.
I go back to Vandenberg's phrase; the question is how Democrats and Republicans can unite our voice “at the water's edge” against those who would divide and conquer us and the free world in Iraq, I add, and beyond.
The danger is that by spending so much attention on the past here, we contribute to a drop in public support among the American people for the war, and that is consequential. Terrorists know they cannot defeat us in Iraq, but they also know they can defeat us in America by breaking the will and steadfast support of the American people for this cause. . .
I worry the partisanship of our time has begun to get in the way of the successful completion of our mission in Iraq. I urge my colleagues at every moment, when we do anything regarding this war that we consider the ideal and we are confident within ourselves. Not that we are stifling free debate. Free debate, as Vandenberg said, is the necessary precondition to the unity we need to maximize our authority against those who would divide and conquer us. But the point is to make sure we feel in ourselves that the aim of our actions and our words is national security, not partisan advantage.
Lefties Forget the "Why"?
I don't get it. WaPo uber-editor Bob Woodward now says he heard Joe Wilson's wife Valerie Plame was a CIA employee in mid-June 2003. But that was prior to the July 6, 2003, NY Times op-ed, where Wilson leaked a phony account of his mission to Niger. So could the left-wing narrative -- Plame's non-existent "cover" was "blown" in retaliation for the op-ed -- be 100 percent wrong?
Actually, I do get it--once again, liberals lie.
MORE:
NRO's Kate O'Beirne:
Actually, I do get it--once again, liberals lie.
MORE:
NRO's Kate O'Beirne:
Walter Pincus and Bob Woodward have different recollections about a possible conversation about Joe Wilson's wife and Woodward has a faulty memory about whether he might have mentioned Wilson's wife to Scooter Libby, and we know that at the NY Times Judith Miller and her editors have different recollections about her desire to pursue the Wilson/Niger story. Why is Scooter Libby the only one with a different recollection than others to be indicted? And, was the Administration official who recently told prosecutor Fitzgerald about a conversation with Woodward not interviewed previously? Who else with knowledge of Plame's employment before it was publicly disclosed wasn't interviewed during a two year long inquiry? Fitzmas is beginning to look like Fitzmissing.Paul at Wizbang:
[W]hen you have a rumor swirling around Washington, you'll never be able to trace it back to the source. It's like trying to figure out who invented your favorite knock knock joke. -- Assuming you have a favorite knock knock joke.
Part of the reason it is so problematic is that despite the DU'ers claims of Roveian omnipotence, there probably never was a single source. . . Probably one tidbit of information started moving then it picked up another bit of information from another person and another and another like a snowball until it lands in Novak's column.
Next thing you know we have a 2 year investigation that still can't get to the bottom of who "leaked" the information. Personally I'll be shocked if they ever charge anyone with the actual leak. Especially if Fitzgerald keeps getting blind-sided with things like this.
Fact Checking Their Ass
The White House fights back against WMD Amnesia. Devastating video here.
Also, Senator Rockefeller keeps plotting Seven Days in May behind closed doors while saying "What, me worry?" in public.
MORE:
RightViews has more ammunition against WMD Amnesia.
Still More:
Norman Podhoretz in Monday's WSJ:
Also, Senator Rockefeller keeps plotting Seven Days in May behind closed doors while saying "What, me worry?" in public.
MORE:
RightViews has more ammunition against WMD Amnesia.
Still More:
Norman Podhoretz in Monday's WSJ:
even stipulating--which I do only for the sake of argument--that no weapons of mass destruction existed in Iraq in the period leading up to the invasion, it defies all reason to think that Mr. Bush was lying when he asserted that they did. To lie means to say something one knows to be false. But it is as close to certainty as we can get that Mr. Bush believed in the truth of what he was saying about WMD in Iraq.(via Gateway Pundit, The Anchoress)
How indeed could it have been otherwise? George Tenet, his own CIA director, assured him that the case was "a slam dunk." This phrase would later become notorious, but in using it, Mr. Tenet had the backing of all 15 agencies involved in gathering intelligence for the United States. In the National Intelligence Estimate of 2002, where their collective views were summarized, one of the conclusions offered with "high confidence" was that "Iraq is continuing, and in some areas expanding its chemical, biological, nuclear, and missile programs contrary to UN resolutions."
The intelligence agencies of Britain, Germany, Russia, China, Israel and--yes--France all agreed with this judgment. And even Hans Blix--who headed the U.N. team of inspectors trying to determine whether Saddam had complied with the demands of the Security Council that he get rid of the weapons of mass destruction he was known to have had in the past--lent further credibility to the case in a report he issued only a few months before the invasion:
The discovery of a number of 122-mm chemical rocket warheads in a bunker at a storage depot 170 km [105 miles] southwest of Baghdad was much publicized. This was a relatively new bunker, and therefore the rockets must have been moved there in the past few years, at a time when Iraq should not have had such munitions. . . . They could also be the tip of a submerged iceberg. The discovery of a few rockets does not resolve but rather points to the issue of several thousands of chemical rockets that are unaccounted for.
Mr. Blix now claims that he was only being "cautious" here, but if, as he now also adds, the Bush administration "misled itself" in interpreting the evidence before it, he at the very least lent it a helping hand. . .
I can't tell you why the French, the Germans, the Brits and us thought that most of the material, if not all of it, that we presented at the U.N. on 5 February 2003 was the truth. I can't. I've wrestled with it. [But] when you see a satellite photograph of all the signs of the chemical-weapons ASP--Ammunition Supply Point--with chemical weapons, and you match all those signs with your matrix on what should show a chemical ASP, and they're there, you have to conclude that it's a chemical ASP, especially when you see the next satellite photograph which shows the UN inspectors wheeling in their white vehicles with black markings on them to that same ASP, and everything is changed, everything is clean. . . . But George [Tenet] was convinced, John McLaughlin [Tenet's deputy] was convinced, that what we were presented [for Powell's UN speech] was accurate. . .
But, according to Wilkerson:The French came in in the middle of my deliberations at the CIA and said, we have just spun aluminum tubes, and by God, we did it to this rpm, et cetera, et cetera, and it was all, you know, proof positive that the aluminum tubes were not for mortar casings or artillery casings, they were for centrifuges. Otherwise, why would you have such exquisite instruments?In short, and whether or not it included the secret heart of Hans Blix, "the consensus of the intelligence community," as Mr. Wilkerson puts it, "was overwhelming" in the period leading up to the invasion of Iraq that Saddam definitely had an arsenal of chemical and biological weapons, and that he was also in all probability well on the way to rebuilding the nuclear capability that the Israelis had damaged by bombing the Osirak reactor in 1981.
Additional confirmation of this latter point comes from Kenneth Pollack, who served in the National Security Council under Clinton. "In the late spring of 2002," Pollack has written:I participated in a Washington meeting about Iraqi WMD. Those present included nearly twenty former inspectors from the United Nations Special Commission (UNSCOM), the force established in 1991 to oversee the elimination of WMD in Iraq. One of the senior people put a question to the group: did anyone in the room doubt that Iraq was currently operating a secret centrifuge plant? No one did. Three people added that they believed Iraq was also operating a secret calutron plant (a facility for separating uranium isotopes).No wonder, then, that another conclusion the NIE of 2002 reached with "high confidence" was that "Iraq could make a nuclear weapon in months to a year once it acquires sufficient weapons-grade fissile material." (Hard as it is to believe, let alone to reconcile with his general position, Joseph C. Wilson IV, in a speech he delivered three months after the invasion at the Education for Peace in Iraq Center, offhandedly made the following remark: "I remain of the view that we will find biological and chemical weapons and we may well find something that indicates that Saddam's regime maintained an interest in nuclear weapons.")
Tuesday, November 15, 2005
GWOT and Pirates
While the US media spills endless ink and fells acres of trees on what Bush said or did not say four years ago, Der Spiegel describes the futuristic weapons in last week's pirate attack of a cruise ship:
(via reader Ken Robinson)
Most of the luxury liner's 151 passengers were still asleep, as the pirates began to open fire with machine guns from two motor boats. With bullets bouncing off the hull, the Norwegian Captain Sven Erik Pedersen warned his guests over the intercom: "Stay inside, we are under attack."If pirates have missiles and pleasure boats have LRAD, what must Al Qaeda have?--and what do US warships need?
Charles Supple, a 78-year-old passenger, pulled his camera just as one of the pirates only 40 meters away steadied a rocket propelled grenade and fired. Supple saw a flash and quickly threw himself on the deck before the shot exploded just overhead. "It was extremely frightening," he said.
The Spirit was in extreme danger and a few of the ship's crew tried to wash the attackers into the sea with fire hoses. But it was a new high-tech weapon that allowed Captain Pedersen to escape the floating villains with only minimal damage to his vessel. In charge of ship security was a fearless former Gurkha -- the elite soldiers from Nepal in the British army. It was he who used a futuristic sonic cannon developed by the Pentagon to send the pirates packing.
Until now, it wasn't widely known that the US Defense Department was sharing the so-called Long Range Acoustic Device (LRAD) with commercial cruise ships. The weapon is essentially a small dish that beams hellishly loud noise that is deafening but not lethal. Weighing 20 kilograms and as big as a TV satellite dish, the device looks deceptively harmless. But once trained on its target, it blasts a tight beam of painful siren-like sound.
It's not known how the grinning pirates 160 kilometers off the coast of the Horn of Africa reacted as they suddenly were hit by the LRAD. But they were close, and the closer one is to the sonic cannon, the worse the effect is. It's possible they received permanent hearing damage, but at the very least they experienced an excruciating headache and ear pain to the point that they could no longer see or hear. They also quickly lost the desire to board the ship.
(via reader Ken Robinson)
Impeach Rockefeller
He may be from one the richest families in the world and a member of the world's most exclusive club, but Senator Jay Rockefeller of West Virginia has a terminal case of Widespread and Massive Democratic Amnesia. Appearing on the "Fox News Sunday" show, host Chris Wallace had little trouble with diagnosis:
(via Best of the Web)
ROCKEFELLER: Chris, it is always the same conversation. You know, it was not the Congress that sent 135,000 or 150,000 troops to--Wallace also showed video of Senator Rockefeller agreeing with Bush in October 2002. saying:
WALLACE: But you voted, sir, and aren't you responsible for your vote?
ROCKFELLER: No. I'm--
WALLACE: You're not? . . .
ROCKEFELLER: I do believe that Iraq poses an imminent threat, but I also believe that after September 11th that question is increasingly outdated.Wallace then drove the point home:
WALLACE: Now, the president never said that Saddam Hussein was an imminent threat. As you saw, you did say that. If anyone hyped the intelligence, isn't it Jay Rockefeller?Game, set and match. As the rich are supposed to say, "Tennis anyone?" No, not you Jay: only a hospital can treat terminal Widespread and Massive Democratic Amnesia. Chris Wallace -- a Democrat, but fair -- can take your Senate seat.
(via Best of the Web)
Monday, November 14, 2005
Flying Flu or Dead Duck?
Writing in the November 21st Weekly Standard, Michael Fumento says bird flu fears are overblown:
(source: Weekly Standard subscription-only .pdf edition, page 27)
What we can say with confidence is that there is never such a thing as helpful hysteria. And the line between informing the public and starting a panic is being crossed every day now by politicians, public health officials, and journalists.This is a serious, supported piece. Read it all. Especially the cartoon:
Officials at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) have been handling numerous fearful phone calls from the public and the media, fielding questions about the safety of bird feeders and Thanksgiving turkeys. "It's been insane," spokesman Dave Daigle told MSNBC. In a recent Q&A session with Wendy Orent, science writer and author of the book Plague, a Nashville resident asked why "don't we just kill off all the domestic birds and poison the food on the migratory bird routes?"
Headlines like "Flu Pandemic Could Kill 150 Million, U.N. Warns" (Reuters) certainly haven't helped. Never mind that the figure was tossed off by a single official who provided a range of "5 million to 150 million." (Translation: "We haven't the foggiest.") Similarly, the media have generally morphed the federal government's leaked estimate of 200,000 to 1.9 million deaths to simply "1.9 million deaths." Also not helping is the media propensity to seek out the most alarmist "experts." . . .
[T]he winner in this grim game of one-upmanship is Dr. Irwin Redlener, director of the National Center for Disaster Preparedness at Columbia University, who claimed on ABC News's Primetime on September 15, "We could have a billion people dying worldwide."
When I later questioned him on this figure, he rather sheepishly admitted he meant to say "one billion ill." Quite a faux pas. But Garrett and Osterholm were on the same show, and neither made a peep to correct the misstatement. ABC used it as part of the introduction. "It could kill a billion people worldwide, make ghost towns out of parts of major cities, and there is not enough medicine to fight it," declared the somber voiceover. "It is called the avian flu." So the billion figure is out there and, no, this single article won't succeed in pulling it back. . .
The key question: What is the likelihood of either of these scenarios? Anybody who gives you an answer other than "No one really knows the risk," as Richard Webby says, is pulling your tail feathers. Webby is a virologist at the Department of Infectious Diseases, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital in Memphis.
There are no pat formulas, such as the chances of shooting snake eyes or drawing a royal flush. Nor is it just a matter of time. Indeed, one of the arguments against a human outbreak of H5N1 is that sick birds have been mixing with humans for years now without producing a pandemic.
It's practically a state secret that the discovery of H5N1 in poultry dates back not to 1997 but rather to 1959, when it was identified in Scottish chickens. Perhaps haggis had a protective effect on the farmers, but there was a terrible outbreak of the related H5N2 among both chickens and turkeys in Pennsylvania in 1983-85 (17 million birds were destroyed) that appears to have originated as H5N1 in seagulls. So H5N1 has been flying around the globe for over four decades and hasn't done a number on us yet. That doesn't mean it won't ever; but there's absolutely no reason to think it will pick this year or next. . .
One panic button now being pushed repeatedly is that half of all persons contracting H5N1 die. "Right now in human beings, it kills 55 percent of the people it infects," Laurie Garrett told ABC's Primetime, on the same show that featured Redlener's billion-death prediction. By comparison, the Spanish flu is believed to have killed 2.5 percent to 5 percent of its victims. The typical flu death rate is less than 1 percent.
The cold-hearted reaction to these reports, paradoxically, is one of relief. A virus that kills its hosts so efficiently cannot easily propagate. (This is one of the reasons Garrett's predicted Ebola pandemic never materialized.) But in fact the reported mortality rate is problematic because of two types of "sample bias."
First, all avian flu deaths so far have occurred in countries with medical systems that are dismal compared with ours. Would you choose a Cambodian hospital to treat your flu? Second, that more or less 50 percent death rate comes from those ill enough to require medical attention--the sickest of the sick. Our experience with normal influenza is that many who become infected have no symptoms at all, nary a sniffle. So we know the numerator, but without the denominator it's useless.
(source: Weekly Standard subscription-only .pdf edition, page 27)Sunday, November 13, 2005
Who Done It?
What caused a two week riot in France? Reciting every nominee would take a thousand monkeys at a thousand typewriters--and would be about as accurate. A partial list:
Certainly, the other factors were relevant. But I agree with SC&A: "There is no single cause, but there is one cause common to all of them -- and Europe isn't going to fix it by tweaking economic policy or banning piggy banks." And it's Islam, not poverty, not skin color, not joblessness, that's straining European "tolerance". Rather, religion is the common denominator, says Mark Steyn in the Spectator (London):
MORE:
Howard at Oraculations: "Root cause? Young guys just love to fight.
(via Cheat Seeking Missiles, A Certain Slant of Light, Publius Pundit, Sigmund, Carl and Alfred and the Sundries Shack)
- mom
- mom's "youths"
- France's overly state-directed economy
- France's weak state institutions
- unworkable multiculturism
- culture
- alienation
- governmental oppression
- isolation imposed by deliberate French apartheid (comments of Faber)
- suburban life in "immigrant districts"
- the paucity of communication between city and suburb
- the "patriarchal structure"
- the reluctance of traditional France (i.e., non-rioters) "to accept the increasingly multiethnic makeup of the nation."
- immigrants from "Black" Africa, as opposed to Maghreb Africa
- too much discrimination
- not enough discrimination, i.e., affirmative action (the WaPo, naturally: when all you have is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail)
- "incipient French racism"
- fear of the "extreme-right"
- because it's "fun"
- coming soon to a newspaper near you, President Bush
- GDP per capita (real; at purchasing power parity) 25 percent less than the US according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (Table 2)
- an unemployment rate (after conforming different counting methodology) of 9.6 percent in September (5.1 percent US)
- unemployment in 2001 among French youth (18-24 years old) was 70.1 percent (35.4 percent US)
- those without jobs in France remain unemployed longer: an average of 12.8 months in 2002 (3.8 months in the US) and 42.9 percent of the unemployed in France in 2003 were unemployed for 12 or more months (11.8 percent US)
- the French tax burden on labor in 2000 was 24.6 percent of GDP (24.1 percent US)
- the overall tax rate in France amounts to 44.2 percent of GDP (25.4 percent US)
- the "social" and "insurance" taxes required of French manufacturers in 2003, on top of wage costs, were 31.1 percent of worker hourly wages (22.1 percent US)
- average hours per employed French worker in 2001 declined to 1532/year (US 1821/yr)
- France's private sector is stunted--twenty-five percent of jobs are as government civil servants; 10 percent of all Frenchmen receive social welfare benefits
- unsurprisingly, in 2003 government spending in France was equivalent to 54.6 percent of GDP (39.2 percent US)
- the rate of return on French equities between 1900 and 2004 averages 3.4 percent (6.8 percent US)
[O]ne widely discussed solution, an increased investment in social programs aimed at these areas, can be rejected out of hand. In fact, the French welfare state has been intensely involved in poor neighborhoods for the past two decades, and that is part of the problem. French policy has created a two-tier system in which the productive are guaranteed jobs and extensive benefits, while the unproductive are guaranteed a basic living with social services far greater than what they would receive in most countries. Yet the very nature of the regulatory-welfare system precludes increasing economic productivity in low-income areas.And Bruce Thornton speculates the "economics only" crowd is on a 60's acid flashback:
To attribute the riot to "frustration" and "no work" is to indulge a highly questionable view of human action that reduces it to environmental forces outside the individual. This materialist determinism — the idea that material causes in the environment, especially economic ones, are the prime mover of humans — is not a scientific fact but an ideological prejudice whose roots lay in pseudo-scientists like Marx and Freud. It discards the fact of human free will.Rather, there's ample data connecting the participants and their targets to Islam. For example, news footage showed rioters chanting "Alluhu Akhbar", not "Onward Christian Soldiers." Second, the riots waned following pleas from French Imams. Further, two synagogues were firebombed--was it a suicide? And it's no coincidence the riots were rooted in "Muslim ghettoes have been no-go areas where the authorities have basically abandoned the responsibilities of government, creating little emirates where the Islamic leaders hold sway."
Certainly, the other factors were relevant. But I agree with SC&A: "There is no single cause, but there is one cause common to all of them -- and Europe isn't going to fix it by tweaking economic policy or banning piggy banks." And it's Islam, not poverty, not skin color, not joblessness, that's straining European "tolerance". Rather, religion is the common denominator, says Mark Steyn in the Spectator (London):
[I]t’s true there are Muslims and there are Muslims: some blow up Tube trains and some rampage through French streets and some claim Mossad’s put something in the chewing gum to make Arab men susceptible to the seduction techniques of Jewesses. Some kill Dutch film-makers and some complain about Piglet coffee mugs on co-workers’ desks, and millions of Muslims don’t do any of the above but apparently don’t feel strongly enough about them to say a word in protest. And it’s also true that it’s better to have your Peugeot torched than to be blown apart on the Piccadilly Line. But what all these techniques — and those of lobby groups who offer themselves as interlocutors between bewildered European elites and ‘moderate’ Muslims — have in common is that they advance the Islamification of Europe.SC&A agrees:
It is religion that is driving these riots- two religions, really. There is the religion of Islam and the religion of entitlement- the same religion that has kept French authorities from entering the suburbs and enforcing the law and the same religion that is reinforced everyday, by religious authorities that have done nothing to change the situation. . .Sure, there were other issues, but the proximate cause is clear, according to Rod Liddle in the Spectator (London):
[Instead, t]here has been no long real attempt at participating in French society- just the opposite, really. French society, like western society, is corrupt and Muslims may not participate. They are Muslims and must live as Muslims (even if that means a bit of rape and a bit of crime). They can extort what they can, live 'on the dole' and protest their sad situation, without regard to reality. Most of all, they can blame everyone else for their own failures.
These ideas did not originate in the Parisian suburbs. They originated in the Middle East, in every Arab country the region. The noble Arab has been the victim, always. All indignities are the result of unfair treatment at the hands of others. Islam and Muslims are being persecuted. That is why Muslims butcher each other- because of others. That is why Muslim societies are monuments to failure- because of others. That is why there are despotic regimes in the region--because of others.
It may well be that the motive for the rioting was nothing more than an inchoate grievance allied to youthful exuberance and a penchant for bad behaviour, but it was Islam which gave it an identity and also its retrospective raison d’être. The political aspirations of many French Muslim organisations and explicitly of the most important political Islamic organisation on the Continent, the Arab European League. . . The appalling Arab European League, in fact, likens assimilation or integration to ‘rape’ and calls upon all Muslims to resist such cultural imperialism. And the director of the Great Mosque of Paris, Dalil Boubakeur, who delivered that nice fatwa, has seemed to request that the French government give Muslims autonomy within the state; to, in effect, allow them to follow their own rules. So for those pundits on French TV, apologies, but au contraire: the French Muslims do not, as a whole, want greater integration. They want less integration.In other words, the failure of French integration is more the fault of Islam than of the native French, as even Marlena Telvick at PBS admits:
This question is inextricably linked to whether Muslim immigrants as a whole are willing to respect Europe's deeply-engrained secular traditions, which Europeans insist is the key component to working towards greater integration. "What Europeans share is a very strong feeling that religion has nothing to do with citizenship," says Harvard's Jocelyne Cesari. "One of the big misunderstandings between Muslims and non-Muslims in Europe has to do with the fact that Muslims have to build a religious minority in a context where religion doesn't make sense anymore in the public space for most Europeans."WSJ reporter John Carreyrou agrees the root cause is specific to Islamic immigrants:
Muslims should identify themselves with their religion rather than as citizens. Effectively, they are promoting a separate society within society and that brand of Islamist philosophy is seeping into many parts of Western Europe. Countries from France and Germany to the United Kingdom and the Netherlands haven't succeeded in integrating their Muslim minorities -- and Islamic organizations have carefully positioned themselves to fill the breach.Finally, DC Watson says it's more creed than color:
They play the race game, claiming to be "oppressed." Perhaps if Muslim immigrants would make an attempt at assimilating into the societies to which they have migrated instead of expecting special privileges because they are Muslims, they would have far less trouble.Why can't France -- or Europe or the United States -- presume immigrants want to be French, Americans, whatever? Why can't most migration be conditioned on leaving old identities, and quarrels, behind? Mark Steyn's answer is profoundly depressing:
[T]he trouble with the social democratic state is that, when government does too much, nobody else does much of anything. At the very least, European citizens should recognise that the governing class has failed, that the conventional wisdom has run its course, and that it is highly unlikely that those culturally confident Muslims will wish to assimilate with anything as shrivelled and barren as contemporary European identity.Conclusion: Is Western Europe -- and possibly Western Civ. -- doomed? Some Islamics plainly hope so. Before abandoning hope, read Dennis Prager's five questions "that law-abiding Muslims need to answer for Islam's sake, as well as for the sake of worried non-Muslims":
- Why are you so quiet?
- Why are none of the Palestinian terrorists Christian?
- Why is only one of the 47 Muslim-majority countries a free country?
- Why are so many atrocities committed and threatened by Muslims in the name of Islam?
- Why do countries governed by religious Muslims persecute other religions?
MORE:
Howard at Oraculations: "Root cause? Young guys just love to fight.
(via Cheat Seeking Missiles, A Certain Slant of Light, Publius Pundit, Sigmund, Carl and Alfred and the Sundries Shack)
Saturday, November 12, 2005
Cognitive Dissonance of the Week
Today's Washington Post includes a front-page article about a Palestinian family, which, when their 12 year-old son died, allowed the dead boy's organs to be harvested and transplanted--to Israelis. Six Israelis, including five Jews, received the Ahmed Khatib's heart, lungs liver and kidneys; since then, one patient died, but the remaining five are recovering. While surprising, the family's decision was touching and admirable.
But there's more to the story and the coverage by the press. The boy was killed by Israelis soldiers in Jenin:

A Palestinian relative mourns at Ahmed Khatb's funeral Nov. 6. The boy's family donated his organs to Israeli patients.
However, the Post's web edition changes the caption:
A relative mourns at Ahmed Khatib's funeral in the West Bank town of Jenin. Next to him, a boy plays with a toy gun.
My questions:
But there's more to the story and the coverage by the press. The boy was killed by Israelis soldiers in Jenin:
To the youths of Ahmed's neighborhood, the gunmen staring from the posters or swaggering around the streets were heroes. Ahmed collected the martyrs' posters, bringing them home only to have his mother tear them up. He threw rocks at army Jeeps. A few days before he died, he left a drawing of a heart on Zbeida's doorstep, said the guerrilla leader, who helped shoulder his coffin to the grave.Accompanying the story is a photo, credited to the Associated Press's Emilio Morenatti, with a print-edition caption written by the Post:
Ahmed . . .was shot twice last week by Israeli soldiers in what the military said was a mistake made during the heat of street fighting near their house. The boy had been holding a toy gun. He died two days later in an Israeli hospital. . .
Ahmad Tawfiq, 11, was standing three feet away when the bullets struck Ahmed that day. He said Ahmed held a toy gun shaped like an Uzi and that the boys stood among five Palestinian fighters exchanging gunfire with Israeli soldiers in Jeeps.

A Palestinian relative mourns at Ahmed Khatb's funeral Nov. 6. The boy's family donated his organs to Israeli patients.
However, the Post's web edition changes the caption:
A relative mourns at Ahmed Khatib's funeral in the West Bank town of Jenin. Next to him, a boy plays with a toy gun.
My questions:
- "Toy" gun? I don't think so--the boy is resting the gun on his knee; the creases in his pants are proof this gun's heavy. Were the gun plastic, the boy would have had it in two hands raised in the air.
- "Playing" with the IDF? Even were the gun fake (which it isn't), one doesn't bring plastic weapons to a front-row seat at the Intifada. Even a twelve year-old knows that; his parents certainly do. But to Palestinians Khatib's death is ammunition for the on going opera "Poor, poor Palestine," in which Israeli soldiers continuously "murder" innocent young Arabs for no reason at all. And the Western press are no better than publicists for the Palestinian's staged production: the WaPo probably edited AP's original caption knowing no reader would believe that Uzi -- made in Israel -- a toy.
- "Mourning" with a machine gun? What kind of people grieve by lining up tomorrow's live-fire target practice? Especially pre-teen boys. I guess mourning means something different in the West Bank.
The Internet Shall Set Ye Free
Jimmy Massey, the Marine with made-up war crimes, has been exposed and debunked. But the damage already's done, via a dozen-plus stories by the Associated Press, USA Today, the Washington Post, the Sacramento Bee and Rolling Stone.
Citizens stopping at the Gateway, rather than riding to the West, were the vanguard--the Post-Dispatch broke the story November 5th. New Yorkers know, courtesy of the NY Post. CNN fans got the news Monday morning. Even slaves to the Strib (far left) and the Seattle Times (moderate) were trusted with the truth. Oh yeah, word's filtered to a few in Georgia, Oklahoma and North Carolina, readers of "The Augusta Chronicle, The Tulsa World and the Charlotte Observer."
But that's about it. As documented by Michelle Malkin, Laer Pearce of Cheat Seeking Missiles and Christopher Fotos at NewsBusters.Org, most of the media hears no error, sees no bias and speaks no correction. Apparently, reporters reasoned readers of USA Today, the Washington Post, the Sacramento Bee, the Associated Press (and newspapers nationwide relying on AP's wire service) can't handle the truth.
In our looking glass world, imagined atrocities are news; "not guilty" is nothing. Among the lefty media, fact checking's only for victory. For the press, good news from Iraq, Iraqi Kurdistan (video) and Afghanistan -- or bad news from France -- is never fit to print.
Citizens stopping at the Gateway, rather than riding to the West, were the vanguard--the Post-Dispatch broke the story November 5th. New Yorkers know, courtesy of the NY Post. CNN fans got the news Monday morning. Even slaves to the Strib (far left) and the Seattle Times (moderate) were trusted with the truth. Oh yeah, word's filtered to a few in Georgia, Oklahoma and North Carolina, readers of "The Augusta Chronicle, The Tulsa World and the Charlotte Observer."
But that's about it. As documented by Michelle Malkin, Laer Pearce of Cheat Seeking Missiles and Christopher Fotos at NewsBusters.Org, most of the media hears no error, sees no bias and speaks no correction. Apparently, reporters reasoned readers of USA Today, the Washington Post, the Sacramento Bee, the Associated Press (and newspapers nationwide relying on AP's wire service) can't handle the truth.
In our looking glass world, imagined atrocities are news; "not guilty" is nothing. Among the lefty media, fact checking's only for victory. For the press, good news from Iraq, Iraqi Kurdistan (video) and Afghanistan -- or bad news from France -- is never fit to print.
Friday, November 11, 2005
Headline Hermeneutics of the Week
Headline--Associated Press, November 9th: Rioting Begins to Slack Off in France
Translation--James Taranto, WSJ's "Best of the Web," November 11th: The French Work Ethic Kicks In
MORE:
From the always brilliant Iowahawk:
Translation--James Taranto, WSJ's "Best of the Web," November 11th: The French Work Ethic Kicks In
MORE:
From the always brilliant Iowahawk:
Complaining of unsafe working conditions, lack of vacation time, and illegal 40-hour weeks, the French Union of Disaffected Immigrant Youth Rioters declared a general strike today.
“We are going to riot and burn cars every night until our demands are met,” warned Musab Al-Dura, a spokesman for the newly formed labor union.
Many analysts feared the surprise walkout could paralyze France’s all-important riot industry, but riot management spokesman Khalil Hassan said that he had received permission from French labor officials and the EU to hire temporary Belgian replacement immigrant rioters to fill positions vacated by rioting domestic French immigrant strikers.
(Un) Clean and Jerks
The only daily comic worth a damn is Tank McNamara, a hilarious strip about sports. Its title character is "a former football star, now working as a sports commentator on TV." Created by Texans Jeff Millar (writer) and Bill Hinds (artist), the cartoon considers sports both high and low--from inspired athleticism to base business; from faithful fans to conspiring crooks. And Tank McNamara's most popular and recurring feature is its year-end contest naming a "Sports Jerk of the Year", "for which readers annually offer thousands of suggestions."
I have a suggestion, which differs in two important ways from previous years:
If neither Selig nor Palmerio are the 2005 jerk-in-chief, it's only because they're overqualified.
I have a suggestion, which differs in two important ways from previous years:
- It's a three-way tie;
- Each appearing in today's sports pages.
- Bud Selig: Selig, Baseball's Commissioner, is part poodle, part Peter Principle--he took office when team owners found Fay Vincent insufficiently fey (i.e., pro-player), his sole qualification being owner of a franchise (the Milwaukee Brewers) with only one good year (World Series runners-up in 1982). Bud did good when he rescued the failing Montreal Expos franchise by first brokering an acquisition by the owners collectively, then moving the team to Washington before the 2005 season.
But that was then. This week, Bud was a bad dog, again postponing the sale of the now Washington Nationals. Originally supposed to be settled in January, then last spring, and then during the season, this week's announcement effectively bars the Nats from the free agency market, which opened a few minutes ago at midnight. It also leaves the teams current manager, coaches and general manager in mid-air, unsure whether they'd be retained by the eventual owners. Bud's stall is particularly unfair to the team's 70 year old manager, Frank Robinson who, after an extraordinary effort this season, can't count on the chance to improve next year. So baseball's delay handicaps the Nationals competitiveness next year--precisely what the remaining owners want. There ought to be a law!--and there would have been were it not for Roe v. Wade author Justice Harry Blackmun. The bad know on which side their bread is buttered. - Terrell Owens: The former San Francisco 49er wide receiver was dealt to the Philadelphia Eagles after a complex arbitration before the start of the 04-05 NFL season. Gifted with guts and great skills, Owens is noxious narcissist, whose pre-season contract dispute and subsequent teammate trash talking led the "Iggles" to suspend TO for the remainder of this season. Though Owens deserves no less, the players union already filed a grievance on his behalf--and the loudmouth likely will prevail under the terms of the collective bargaining agreement. Whatever the arbitration's answer, TO's finished in Philadelphia, depriving his team of its best player, likely ending the Eagles NFC title game appearance streak at three years. No one -- not the bratty Owens nor even TO's obnoxious agent Drew Rosenhaus -- comes out ahead.
- Rafael Palmeiro: Cuban-born and a 20 year baseball veteran, Palmerio was a fan favorite in two stints each with the Texas Rangers and Baltimore Orioles. And when not hawking little blue pills, he seemed a Hall of Fame lock when, on July 15th, he became only the fourth player to have 500 home runs and 3000 hits.
One problem: he was expelled from Harvard for cheating by having someone else take his Spanish exam . No, wait, that was Ted Kennedy. Palmeiro's fine with Spanish; he just has a problem with truth. Long rumored to be on steroids -- he hit only 22 home runs in 1992, the season he was joined in Texas by a new teammate named Jose Canseco. And then hit 37 the next year and at least 38 in the next nine non-strike seasons after that -- he emphatically denied using performance-enhancing drugs in a dramitic Capitol Hill hearing:On March 17, Palmeiro, Orioles teammate Sammy Sosa and retired sluggers Jose Canseco and Mark McGwire testified before the House Government Reform Committee investigating steroid use in professional sports. Emphatically pointing a finger toward legislators as he spoke, Palmeiro testified that "I have never used steroids. Period."
Washington Post baseball columnist Tom Boswell explained the subtext:
The panel found Palmeiro's testimony so compelling that he was asked to join a task force on steroids.Palmeiro pointed his finger for emphasis, a gesture that was universally understood. He was pushing all his chips, accumulated over a career, into the center of the table. All his well-known civic and charitable good deeds, his reputation as a clean player, were shoved into the pot to counterbalance the charge, made by Jose Canseco, that Canseco had injected Palmeiro with steroids on many occasions when they were teammates.
But less than a month after his 3000th hit, Palmeiro was suspended from baseball after testing positively for the steroid stanozolol. Though Congress won't press perjury charges, Palmerio probably injected himself out of an Oriole's uniform. He didn't help his case this week by continuing to deny intentional steroid use, insisting he was framed. Once admired by all, Palmero went from glory to goat in less than a year, managing the impossible--bolstering Jose Canseco's credibility. And that's truly ugly.
If neither Selig nor Palmerio are the 2005 jerk-in-chief, it's only because they're overqualified.
Thursday, November 10, 2005
Were They Watching A Movie?
EU Rota reprints France as seen by NY Times Columnist/economist Paul Krugman--the illustrated version. SC&A gapes at the Arab press--which blames the victims (assist, USA Today contributing board) and frets over threats to practicing Muslim in the West without mentioning the safety or religious freedom of Christians and Jews (particularly converts) in Muslim lands. MaxedOutMama shows thugs blaming the cops, the government blaming gangs, while the press in Germany and France desperately dodge impugning Islam--and blue-pencil the facts. Finally, though Ralph Peters starts on level ground . . .:
Welcome to "Bizzaro World." I blame Foucault.
Paralyzed French officials complain of "unfair" media attention (welcome to the reality club, Pierre). Yet, hardly two months ago the French media celebrated the suffering in New Orleans — ignoring the brave response of millions of Americans to Hurricane Katrina to concentrate exclusively on the Crescent City's lower 9th ward and one nutty, incompetent mayor.. . . his NY Post Op Ed concludes: "every American who believes in racial equality and human dignity should sympathize with the rioters, not with the effete bigots on the Seine." Uh, WTF?
Utterly devoid of self-awareness, the French cherish their image of America as racist. But minorities in the United States have opportunities for which their French counterparts would risk their lives. Our problem is that demagogues convince the poorest of our poor to give up on getting ahead. In France, the non-white poor never have a chance of any kind.
France has no Colin Powell or Condi Rice, no minority heading the equivalent of a Fortune 500 company, no vibrant minority political culture. When Americans who adore la vie en France go to Paris (the intelligentsia's Orlando), they don't visit the drug-and-crime-plagued slums. If tourists encounter a Moroccan or a Senegalese "Frenchman," he's cleaning up the sidewalks after the dogs of the bourgeoisie.
Willfully blind to reality, liberals continue to praise the racist culture of France by citing the Parisian welcome for Josephine Baker or the Harlem jazz musicians in the 1920s. But the French regarded those few as exotic pets. The test is how they treat the millions of immigrant families whose members don't play trumpets in bars or sell their flesh in strip clubs.
There is no Western country more profoundly racist than France. . .
Meanwhile, the Chirac government is stunned. Its members truly believed that supporting Arab and African dictators and defying America's efforts to liberate tens of millions of Muslims would buy safety from the 5 million immigrants and their children who have not the slightest hope of a decent future.
Welcome to "Bizzaro World." I blame Foucault.
Only A Pawn in their Game1
As the NY Times shoved scandal-scarred reporter Judith Miller out the window, John Hawkins at Right Wing News offers quotes from journalists and friends who knew Valerie Plame worked for the CIA long before what lefties falsely call a "retaliatory outing" by the Bush Administration. Of course, as previously shown, the best evidence Ms Joseph Wilson wasn't a covert agent comes from Mr Joseph Wilson, interviewed by Wolf Blitzer on CNN:
Until recently, the left wing media agreed. Lately, the phony "Plame-gate" metastasized into, as a minimum, a baseball bat for biased Bush bashing or, more often, a weapon of mass destruction in the CIA's long-standing war on the Administration.
Why isn't that more widely disseminated and discussed?
_____________________
1 See B. Dylan, Only a Pawn in Their Game (1964).
WILSON: My wife was not a clandestine officer the day that Bob Novak blew her identity.This could hardly be more clear, right?
Until recently, the left wing media agreed. Lately, the phony "Plame-gate" metastasized into, as a minimum, a baseball bat for biased Bush bashing or, more often, a weapon of mass destruction in the CIA's long-standing war on the Administration.
Why isn't that more widely disseminated and discussed?
_____________________
1 See B. Dylan, Only a Pawn in Their Game (1964).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
